García-Parra Patricia, Pérez Fernández Ángela, Djorojevic Mirjana, Botella Miguel, Alemán Inmaculada
Department of Legal Medicine, Toxicology and Physical Anthropology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Granada, Avda de Madrid, Granada, n°11, C.P 18012, Spain.
Department of Legal Medicine, Toxicology and Physical Anthropology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Granada, Avda de Madrid, Granada, n°11, C.P 18012, Spain.
Forensic Sci Int. 2014 Nov;244:313.e1-9. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2014.06.019. Epub 2014 Jun 26.
Sex estimation is one of the first steps in forensic anthropology to identify human remains. In absence of the skull or the pelvis, any skeletal remain becomes fundamental for identification, especially in mass-disaster cases. The sternum is a potentially useful element in anthropological analysis with a high recovery rate in both forensic-and archaeological context. This study aims to develop classification functions for use in Spanish population. For this, sternum sexual dimorphism is studied in a sample of 105 individuals, known age-at-death, ancestry and sex, from San José Municipal Cemetery of Granada (Spain). Lin's concordance correlation coefficient was used to estimate intra-and inter-observer error. In discriminant analysis for estimating sex, cross-validation shows accuracy rates exceeds 90% for sternum body length and maximum width (91.8%), or total length with maximum width (90.7%). Isolated variables with higher accuracy rates are total sternum length (89.1%), and sternum body length (87%). Although there is compliance with Hyrtl's law it is not useful for estimating sex in Spanish population. These discriminant functions have also been validated successfully in two samples from Portugal (Coimbra identified skeletal collection--CISC, and 21st century identified ckeletal collection--Santarém XXI): the variables with higher accuracy rates sternum total length with its maximum width (92.3% the correctly classified individual in the sample CISC; and 83.5% in the sample of Santarém XXI) and the sternum total length (92.1% and 78.5%, respectively). The discriminant functions achieved with the collection of the San Jose cemetery of Granada can be applied to current remains, provided that study populations present a similar sexual dimorphism, like the two samples from Portuguese population presented in this study.
性别估计是法医人类学中识别遗骸的首要步骤之一。在没有头骨或骨盆的情况下,任何骨骼遗骸都成为识别的关键,尤其是在大规模灾难事件中。胸骨是人类学分析中一个潜在有用的元素,在法医和考古背景下的回收率都很高。本研究旨在开发适用于西班牙人群的分类函数。为此,在来自西班牙格拉纳达圣何塞市公墓的105名已知死亡年龄、血统和性别的个体样本中研究了胸骨的性别二态性。使用林氏一致性相关系数来估计观察者内部和观察者之间的误差。在估计性别的判别分析中,交叉验证显示胸骨体长和最大宽度(91.8%)或全长与最大宽度(90.7%)的准确率超过90%。准确率较高的孤立变量是胸骨全长(89.1%)和胸骨体长(87%)。尽管符合希尔特尔定律,但它对估计西班牙人群的性别并无用处。这些判别函数也已在来自葡萄牙的两个样本(科英布拉已识别骨骼收藏——CISC,以及21世纪已识别骨骼收藏——桑塔雷姆二十一世纪)中成功验证:准确率较高的变量是胸骨全长及其最大宽度(在CISC样本中正确分类的个体为92.3%;在桑塔雷姆二十一世纪样本中为83.5%)以及胸骨全长(分别为92.1%和78.5%)。只要研究人群呈现出类似的性别二态性,就像本研究中呈现的来自葡萄牙人群的两个样本那样,用格拉纳达圣何塞公墓的样本得出的判别函数就可以应用于当前的遗骸。