Ortiz V, Poppele G, Alonso N, Castellano C, Garrigues V
Digestive Functional Disorders Unit, Gastroenterology Department, Hospital Universitari i Politècnic La Fe, Valencia, Spain.
Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2014 Nov;26(11):1551-6. doi: 10.1111/nmo.12415. Epub 2014 Aug 14.
Relaxation of the esophagogastric junction (EGJ) is now evaluated calculating 4-second integrated relaxation pressure (4-s IRP) by high resolution manometry (HREPT). Solid-state catheters have been used to define abnormal values. Our aim was to evaluate 4-s IRP in esophageal achalasia using HREPT with perfused catheters.
From June 2009 to June 2013, 936 HREPT studies have been performed in our unit. Of these, 194 patients having treated achalasia were excluded. Control group was constituted by 695 patients without achalasia, and 47 patients with untreated achalasia constituted the study group. HREPT was performed with water-perfused catheters. To establish the cut-off value for 4-s IRP that better discriminate patients with achalasia from all other patients, a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was performed.
Twenty three of 47 achalasia patients (49%) showed a 4-s IRP under 15 mmHg; and seven (15%) had a value under modified Chicago criteria. A cut-off value for 4-s IRP of 6.5 mmHg, calculated by ROC analysis, highly discriminates achalasia from the rest of the patients and especially from scleroderma patients (area under the curve: 0.997, 95% CI: 0.995-1.000; p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS & INFERENCES: Cut-off values for 4-s IRP defined using HREPT with solid-state catheters are not adequate for diagnosing esophageal achalasia with water-perfused systems. A lower value, i.e., 6.5 mmHg, is suggested for this equipment. The diagnostic criteria of esophageal achalasia should be modified for HREPT performed with water-perfused systems.
目前通过高分辨率食管测压法(HREPT)计算4秒综合松弛压(4-s IRP)来评估食管胃交界处(EGJ)的松弛情况。固态导管已被用于定义异常值。我们的目的是使用灌注导管的HREPT评估食管失弛缓症患者的4-s IRP。
2009年6月至2013年6月,我们科室共进行了936例HREPT检查。其中,194例已治疗的失弛缓症患者被排除。对照组由695例无失弛缓症的患者组成,47例未经治疗的失弛缓症患者构成研究组。使用水灌注导管进行HREPT检查。为确定能更好地区分失弛缓症患者与其他所有患者的4-s IRP临界值,进行了受试者操作特征(ROC)分析。
47例失弛缓症患者中有23例(49%)的4-s IRP低于15 mmHg;7例(15%)的值低于改良芝加哥标准。通过ROC分析计算得出的4-s IRP临界值为6.5 mmHg,该值能很好地区分失弛缓症患者与其他患者,尤其是与硬皮病患者(曲线下面积:0.997,95%可信区间:0.995 - 1.000;p < 0.001)。
使用固态导管的HREPT所定义的4-s IRP临界值不适用于诊断水灌注系统下的食管失弛缓症。对于该设备,建议采用较低的临界值,即6.5 mmHg。对于使用水灌注系统进行的HREPT,食管失弛缓症的诊断标准应予以修改。