Varlokosta Spyridoula, Nerantzini Michaela, Papadopoulou Despina
Department of Linguistics,School of Philology,University of Athens.
Department of Linguistics,School of Philology,Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
J Child Lang. 2015 May;42(3):618-61. doi: 10.1017/S0305000914000257. Epub 2014 Aug 15.
Cross-linguistic studies have shown that typically developing children have difficulties comprehending non-canonical structures. These findings have been interpreted within the Relativized Minimality (RM) approach, according to which local relations cannot be established between two terms of a dependency if an intervening element possesses similar morphosyntactic features. In an extension of RM, Friedmann, Belletti, and Rizzi (2009) suggested that lexical NP restriction is the source of minimality effects in non-canonical sentences. The present study aimed at investigating whether the predictions of their account can be confirmed in Greek. Our results indicate that although lexical NP restriction is a crucial factor in generating minimality effects, it is not always sufficient to account for the comprehension difficulties that young children face with non-canonical sentences, since the internal structure (i.e. the feature specification) of the moved element and of the intervener affects their performance, as well.
跨语言研究表明,发育正常的儿童在理解非规范结构方面存在困难。这些发现是在相对最小化(RM)方法的框架内进行解释的,根据该方法,如果一个介入成分具有相似的形态句法特征,那么在依存关系的两个项之间就无法建立局部关系。在RM的一个扩展中,弗里德曼、贝莱蒂和里齐(2009)提出,词汇性名词短语限制是非规范句子中最小化效应的来源。本研究旨在调查他们的观点预测在希腊语中是否能够得到证实。我们的结果表明,虽然词汇性名词短语限制是产生最小化效应的一个关键因素,但它并不总是足以解释幼儿在非规范句子理解上所面临的困难,因为被移动成分和介入成分的内部结构(即特征规格)也会影响他们的表现。