Millen A, Coulston J, Brennan J, Kennedy T
Clinical Research Fellow, Royal Liverpool University Hospital; UK.
J Wound Care. 2014 Aug;23(8):388-92. doi: 10.12968/jowc.2014.23.8.388.
Lower limb ulcers that are resistant to standard forms of treatment place a significant burden on both patients and health services. There is no widely agreed definition of a recalcitrant ulcer but failure to heal following 6-12 months of focused treatment would identify a small group of patients with highly resistant ulceration. We describe a series of patients with recalcitrant ulceration for which immunosuppressive agents have been used.
This is a case series of 13 patients who underwent immunomodulation therapy for lower limb ulcers at a tertiary referral university hospital. Regimens of immunomodulation used mainly ciclosporin and/or cyclophosphamide, with concurrent antibiotic therapy. Case notes and computer systems were analysed by two reviewers. A patient was deemed to have a success if their ulcer fully healed while on immunomodulation therapy.
Over a period of eight years, from 2004-2012, 13 patients underwent immunomodulation therapy. Among these patients there were 18 ulcerated limbs. Ulcer healing occurred in 10 limbs out of 18 (55.6%) and full healing occurred in six patients (46.2%). Ulcers were present for a median of five years (range 2-40 years), with a median diameter of 7.5 cm (range 4-18 cm) before treatment.
Treatment of truly recalcitrant ulceration can be very frustrating for both the patient and physician, with poor success from more standard forms of treatment. We report experience with immunomodulation therapy that suggests there may be benefit from using this treatment in a subset of patients with this debilitating disease.
对标准治疗方式耐药的下肢溃疡给患者和医疗服务带来了沉重负担。对于顽固性溃疡尚无广泛认可的定义,但经过6至12个月的针对性治疗仍未愈合,可确定一小部分溃疡高度耐药的患者。我们描述了一系列使用免疫抑制剂治疗的顽固性溃疡患者。
这是一个病例系列,包含13例在一所三级转诊大学医院接受下肢溃疡免疫调节治疗的患者。免疫调节方案主要使用环孢素和/或环磷酰胺,并同时进行抗生素治疗。两位研究者分析了病历和计算机系统记录。如果患者在免疫调节治疗期间溃疡完全愈合,则判定为治疗成功。
在2004年至2012年的八年时间里,13例患者接受了免疫调节治疗。这些患者中有18条肢体出现溃疡。18条肢体中的10条(55.6%)溃疡愈合,6例患者(46.2%)完全愈合。溃疡存在的中位时间为5年(范围2至40年),治疗前溃疡中位直径为7.5厘米(范围4至18厘米)。
对于真正顽固性溃疡的治疗,患者和医生都会感到非常沮丧,标准治疗方式的成功率很低。我们报告了免疫调节治疗的经验,提示在一部分患有这种使人衰弱疾病的患者中使用这种治疗可能有益。