Leinenger Mallorie
University of California, San Diego.
Psychol Bull. 2014 Nov;140(6):1534-55. doi: 10.1037/a0037830. Epub 2014 Aug 25.
The exact role that phonological coding (the recoding of written, orthographic information into a sound based code) plays during silent reading has been extensively studied for more than a century. Despite the large body of research surrounding the topic, varying theories as to the time course and function of this recoding still exist. The present review synthesizes this body of research, addressing the topics of time course and function in tandem. The varying theories surrounding the function of phonological coding (e.g., that phonological codes aid lexical access, that phonological codes aid comprehension and bolster short-term memory, or that phonological codes are largely epiphenomenal in skilled readers) are first outlined, and the time courses that each maps onto (e.g., that phonological codes come online early [prelexical] or that phonological codes come online late [postlexical]) are discussed. Next the research relevant to each of these proposed functions is reviewed, discussing the varying methodologies that have been used to investigate phonological coding (e.g., response time methods, reading while eye-tracking or recording EEG and MEG, concurrent articulation) and highlighting the advantages and limitations of each with respect to the study of phonological coding. In response to the view that phonological coding is largely epiphenomenal in skilled readers, research on the use of phonological codes in prelingually, profoundly deaf readers is reviewed. Finally, implications for current models of word identification (activation-verification model, Van Orden, 1987; dual-route model, e.g., M. Coltheart, Rastle, Perry, Langdon, & Ziegler, 2001; parallel distributed processing model, Seidenberg & McClelland, 1989) are discussed.
在默读过程中,语音编码(即把书面的正字法信息重新编码为基于声音的代码)所起的确切作用已被广泛研究了一个多世纪。尽管围绕该主题有大量研究,但关于这种重新编码的时间进程和功能仍存在不同理论。本综述综合了这一系列研究,同时探讨时间进程和功能这两个主题。首先概述围绕语音编码功能的不同理论(例如,语音代码有助于词汇通达,语音代码有助于理解并增强短期记忆,或者语音代码在熟练读者中很大程度上是附带现象),并讨论每种理论所对应的时间进程(例如,语音代码在早期[词汇前]启用,或者语音代码在后期[词汇后]启用)。接下来回顾与这些提出的功能相关的研究,讨论用于研究语音编码的不同方法(例如,反应时间方法、眼动追踪或记录脑电图和脑磁图时阅读、同时发音),并突出每种方法在语音编码研究方面的优点和局限性。针对语音编码在熟练读者中很大程度上是附带现象这一观点,综述了关于先天性深度聋读者使用语音代码的研究。最后,讨论了对当前单词识别模型(激活验证模型,范·奥登,1987;双通道模型,例如,M. 科尔特哈特、拉斯特尔、佩里、兰登和齐格勒,2001;并行分布式处理模型,塞登伯格和麦克莱兰,1989)的影响。