Destors J M, Boissel J P, Philippon A M, Schbath J
Unité de Pharmacologie Clinique, Hôpital Neuro-Cardiologique, Lyon, France.
Fundam Clin Pharmacol. 1989;3(6):597-611. doi: 10.1111/j.1472-8206.1989.tb00462.x.
191 patients with exercise induced angina pectoris and a mean weekly number of attacks of 11.3 were admitted in a multicentre double-blind study after an evaluation period on placebo. They were randomly assigned to: bepridil (100-400 mg/d), propranolol (60-240 mg/d), placebo ("strength" 100-400) and treated for 6 months. During the first 8 weeks the treatment was individually titrated. Withdrawal from the study was considered as "failure". 19.2% bepridil patients, 21.8% propanolol patients and 17.1% placebo patients stopped their study medication. Severe angina pectoris leading to withdrawal was not observed in bepridil group against 3 cases in placebo (P = 0.03) and 6 in propanolol groups (P = 0.02). In all groups the number of attacks was reduced between 49 and 77%. At wk 8, bepridil patients were improved compared with placebo patients (P = 0.04). Total work performed and duration of exercise on the ergometer were increased in bepridil patients at wk 8 compared with placebo patients. However, all treatment differences had vanished by wk 24. One patient died in the bepridil group, 2 in the propranolol group and none in the placebo group. The total numbers of fatal or severe non fatal cardiovascular events were not statistically significantly different. There were less severe adverse cardiovascular reactions in the bepridil group than in the propranolol group (P less than 0.03).
191例运动诱发型心绞痛患者,平均每周发作次数为11.3次,在经过安慰剂评估期后,进入一项多中心双盲研究。他们被随机分为:苄普地尔组(100 - 400毫克/天)、普萘洛尔组(60 - 240毫克/天)、安慰剂组(“强度”100 - 400),并接受6个月的治疗。在最初的8周内,治疗进行个体化滴定。退出研究被视为“治疗失败”。19.2%的苄普地尔组患者、21.8%的普萘洛尔组患者和17.1%的安慰剂组患者停止服用研究药物。苄普地尔组未观察到因严重心绞痛导致退出研究的情况,而安慰剂组有3例(P = 0.03),普萘洛尔组有6例(P = 0.02)。所有组的发作次数减少了49%至77%。在第8周时,苄普地尔组患者与安慰剂组患者相比有所改善(P = 0.04)。与安慰剂组患者相比,苄普地尔组患者在第8周时在测力计上完成的总工作量和运动持续时间增加。然而,到第24周时,所有治疗差异均消失。苄普地尔组有1例患者死亡,普萘洛尔组有2例患者死亡,安慰剂组无死亡病例。致命或严重非致命心血管事件的总数在统计学上无显著差异。苄普地尔组严重不良心血管反应比普萘洛尔组少(P小于0.03)。