Chiang Silvia S, Cruz Andrea T, Del Castillo Hernán, Contreras Carmen, Becerra Mercedes C, Lecca Leonid
Paediatr Int Child Health. 2015 Feb;35(1):29-35. doi: 10.1179/2046905514Y.0000000143. Epub 2014 Aug 27.
As most national tuberculosis programmes (NTPs) focus on adult tuberculosis (TB), NTP providers may not appreciate differences in the pathophysiology and presentation of childhood TB.
This study aimed to identify strengths and weaknesses in knowledge of childhood TB among the 326 NTP providers in Lima Ciudad and Lima Este--two of the Peruvian capital's four health districts.
310 providers--103 physicians, 106 nurses, 101 nursing technicians--accepted personal invitations to complete self-administered surveys, which included 14 childhood TB questions grouped into five sections: transmission, symptoms, diagnosis, prevention and treatment. Physicians were asked ten additional questions targeting their NTP diagnostic and management responsibilities.
All three groups scored 97-99% on the transmission section and 83-85% on the treatment section; however, no group scored above 66% on any other section. Fewer than 50% of nurses and technicians recognised young children's high risk of extrapulmonary TB, extrapulmonary TB symptoms or the causes of false negative tuberculin skin tests. Twenty-three per cent of physicians correctly identified gastric aspirate culture sensitivity, and 42% the radiographical findings of pulmonary TB. Less than two-thirds of providers recognised the definition of latent TB infection (LTBI), young children's high risk of progression from LTBI to disease or indications for isoniazid preventive therapy.
Providers at the frontline of Peru's TB control efforts demonstrated weaknesses in the areas of extrapulmonary disease, diagnosis and prevention. These knowledge gaps are likely to have resulted in delayed or missed diagnoses and lost opportunities for prevention. Educational interventions targeting NTP personnel may improve childhood TB care and outcomes.
由于大多数国家结核病规划(NTP)专注于成人结核病(TB),NTP的工作人员可能并不了解儿童结核病在病理生理学和临床表现方面的差异。
本研究旨在确定利马市和利马东部这两个秘鲁首都四个健康区中的326名NTP工作人员对儿童结核病知识的优势和不足。
310名工作人员——103名医生、106名护士、101名护理技术员——接受个人邀请,完成自行填写的调查问卷,其中包括14个关于儿童结核病的问题,分为五个部分:传播、症状、诊断、预防和治疗。医生还被问及另外10个针对其在NTP诊断和管理职责的问题。
所有三组在传播部分的得分均为97 - 99%,在治疗部分的得分均为83 - 85%;然而,在其他任何部分,没有一组得分超过66%。不到50%的护士和技术员认识到幼儿肺外结核的高风险、肺外结核症状或结核菌素皮肤试验假阴性的原因。23%的医生正确识别了胃液培养敏感性,42%正确识别了肺结核的影像学表现。不到三分之二的工作人员认识到潜伏性结核感染(LTBI)的定义、幼儿从LTBI进展为疾病的高风险或异烟肼预防性治疗的指征。
秘鲁结核病防控工作一线的工作人员在肺外疾病、诊断和预防方面存在不足。这些知识差距可能导致诊断延迟或漏诊以及预防机会的丧失。针对NTP人员的教育干预可能会改善儿童结核病的护理和结局。