Jung Changmi, Padman Rema
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21202, USA.
Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA.
Int J Med Inform. 2014 Dec;83(12):901-14. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2014.08.004. Epub 2014 Aug 17.
Virtualization of healthcare delivery via patient portals has facilitated the increasing interest in online medical consultations due to its benefits such as improved convenience and flexibility, lower cost, and time savings. Despite this growing interest, adoption by both consumers and providers has been slow, and little is known about users and their usage and adoption patterns.
To learn characteristics of online healthcare consumers and understand their patterns of adoption and usage of online clinical consultation services (or eVisits delivered via the portal) such as adoption time for portal users, whether adoption hazard changes over time, and what factors influence patients to become early/late adopters.
Using online medical consultation records between April 1, 2009 and May 31, 2010 from four ambulatory practices affiliated with a major healthcare provider, we conduct simple descriptive analysis to understand the users of online clinical consults and their usage patterns. Multilevel Logit regression is employed to measure the effect of patient and primary care provider characteristics on the likelihood of eVisit adoption by the patient, and survival analysis and Ordered Logit regression are applied to study eVisit adoption patterns that delineate elements describing early or late adopters.
On average, eVisit adopters are younger and predominantly female. Their primary care providers participate in the eVisit service, highlighting the importance of physician's role in encouraging patients to utilize the service. Patients who are familiar with the patient portal are more likely to use the service, as are patients with more complex health issues. Younger and female patients have higher adoption hazard, but gender does not affect the decision of adopting early vs. late. These adopters also access the patient portal more frequently before adoption, indicating that they are potentially more involved in managing their health. The majority of eVisits are submitted during business hours, with female physicians responding faster (from submission to reply), on average.
This study addresses virtualization of primary care delivery via patient portals and online clinical consultations and examines factors that distinguish eVisit adopters from patient portal users. Among many delineating characteristics, it is particularly significant that familiarity with the patient portal service and participation of primary care provider are found to be key elements that motivate patients to become an eVisit user and early/late adopter. These findings can be used by provider organizations to design and implement strategies to improve uptake of online medical consultations to complement traditional office visits. Offering such alternative channels of care delivery may potentially improve access, efficiency and outcomes for both patients and providers alike.
通过患者门户网站实现医疗服务的虚拟化,因其具有提高便利性和灵活性、降低成本以及节省时间等优点,促进了人们对在线医疗咨询的兴趣日益浓厚。尽管兴趣不断增加,但消费者和提供者的采用率一直很低,而且对于用户及其使用和采用模式知之甚少。
了解在线医疗消费者的特征,并了解他们采用和使用在线临床咨询服务(或通过门户网站提供的电子就诊)的模式,例如门户网站用户的采用时间、采用风险是否随时间变化,以及哪些因素影响患者成为早期/晚期采用者。
利用一家大型医疗服务提供商下属的四家门诊机构在2009年4月1日至2010年5月31日期间的在线医疗咨询记录,我们进行简单的描述性分析,以了解在线临床咨询的用户及其使用模式。采用多水平Logit回归来衡量患者和初级保健提供者的特征对患者采用电子就诊可能性的影响,并应用生存分析和有序Logit回归来研究电子就诊采用模式,该模式描绘了描述早期或晚期采用者的要素。
平均而言,电子就诊采用者更年轻,且主要为女性。他们初级保健提供者参与电子就诊服务,突出了医生在鼓励患者使用该服务方面的作用。熟悉患者门户网站的患者更有可能使用该服务,健康问题更复杂的患者也是如此。年轻和女性患者的采用风险更高,但性别并不影响早期或晚期采用的决定。这些采用者在采用之前也更频繁地访问患者门户网站,这表明他们可能更积极参与自身健康管理。大多数电子就诊在工作时间提交,平均而言,女医生回复更快(从提交到回复)。
本研究探讨了通过患者门户网站和在线临床咨询实现初级保健服务的虚拟化,并研究了区分电子就诊采用者与患者门户网站用户的因素。在众多区分特征中,特别重要的是发现熟悉患者门户网站服务和初级保健提供者的参与是促使患者成为电子就诊用户和早期/晚期采用者的关键因素。这些发现可供医疗服务机构用于设计和实施策略,以提高在线医疗咨询的使用率,作为传统门诊就诊的补充。提供这样的替代护理渠道可能会改善患者和提供者双方的可及性、效率和治疗效果。