From the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Great Lakes Healthcare System, Tomah, WI.
Neurology. 2014 Sep 9;83(11):1025-8. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000000784.
During the US Civil War, medical officers typically attributed night blindness among soldiers to malingering. A dietary basis was not generally suspected or appreciated.
DESIGN/METHODS: Incident cases of night blindness, scurvy, and diarrheal diseases, as well as mean troop strength among Union troops, were abstracted by month and race from tabulations of the US Surgeon General for the period from July 1861 through June 1866. Monthly incidence rates and annual incidence rates are presented as time series by race.
Night blindness incidence was seasonal. Seasonal patterns of night blindness incidence were similar for white and black soldiers, although the peak incidence rates were approximately 2-3 times higher in black soldiers. The seasonal effect for white Union soldiers increased progressively to 1864. The seasonal pattern for night blindness roughly parallels that for scurvy and for diarrheal diseases. The peak season for night blindness incidence was summer, and the next highest season was spring. The mode of monthly incidence rates for diarrheal diseases slightly anticipated that for night blindness and scurvy. In addition, there was greater relative variation in monthly incidence for night blindness and scurvy than for diarrheal diseases.
Nutritional night blindness occurred in a seasonal pattern among soldiers forced to subsist on nutritionally inadequate diets. The seasonal pattern is consistent with seasonal variations in the availability of foodstuffs with high vitamin A or provitamin A content, superimposed on marginal vitamin A reserves, and possibly exacerbated by co-occurring seasonal patterns of diarrheal disease.
在美国内战期间,军医通常将士兵的夜盲症归因于装病。一般不会怀疑或意识到这是饮食问题。
方法/设计:从美国军医署 1861 年 7 月至 1866 年 6 月的数据中,按月和种族提取夜盲症、坏血病和腹泻病的病例以及联邦军队的平均兵力。按种族呈现逐月发病率和年度发病率的时间序列。
夜盲症的发病率具有季节性。白人和黑人士兵的夜盲症发病率呈季节性模式相似,尽管黑人士兵的发病率峰值约高出 2-3 倍。白人联邦士兵的季节性效应逐渐增加到 1864 年。夜盲症的季节性模式与坏血病和腹泻病大致相似。夜盲症发病率的高峰期在夏季,其次是春季。腹泻病的月发病率模式略先于夜盲症和坏血病。此外,夜盲症和坏血病的月发病率变化比腹泻病更大。
在被迫食用营养不足的饮食的士兵中,营养性夜盲症呈季节性模式发生。这种季节性模式与富含维生素 A 或维生素 A 前体的食物供应的季节性变化一致,这些食物的供应情况叠加在边缘维生素 A 储备之上,可能因同时发生的季节性腹泻病模式而加剧。