Warren Ricks, Burrow Julia, Conroy Deirdre, Lukela Jennifer, Kahn David A
WARREN, BURROW, CONROY, and LUKELA: University of Michigan Department of Psychiatry, Ann Arbor.
J Psychiatr Pract. 2014 Sep;20(5):379-88. doi: 10.1097/01.pra.0000454785.97976.4d.
"Sudden gains" is a robust phenomenon that has been found to occur among a variety of psychotherapies, clinical conditions, settings, patient populations, and differing levels of therapist expertise. Sudden gains predict superior end-of-treatment outcomes and long-term maintenance of gains. While cognitive changes during the critical session appear to account for the sudden gains, the nature of these changes has not been fully explained, and no detailed reports of how therapists and patients explain these changes have been presented. This case involved a 61-year-old woman with depression, fibromyalgia, and severe osteoarthritis who, after being in psychotherapy treatment for nearly a year, achieved sudden gains after one particular psychotherapy session. The authors discuss the nature of the cognitive changes that both the patient and therapist understood to occur during that critical session and that they believed contributed to the remission of major depressive disorder over a 2-year period. This case study also explores the possible synergistic effects of medications and cognitive interventions on sudden gains. The commentary on the case links this discussion of sudden gains to an intervention created by Viederman and Perry in the 1980s called the psychodynamic life narrative, which they found could sometimes alleviate symptoms rapidly and dramatically by reframing a person's self-image during a depressive crisis, especially one related to a feeling of despair triggered by medical illness. An increased understanding of the nature of interventions that produce cognitive changes leading to immediate, dramatic, and lasting improvement could potentially contribute to the development of more effective treatments for depression and other clinical conditions.
“突然改善”是一种普遍存在的现象,在各种心理治疗、临床病症、治疗环境、患者群体以及不同水平的治疗师专业技能中均有发现。突然改善预示着治疗结束时的更好结果以及改善情况的长期维持。虽然关键治疗时段中的认知变化似乎可以解释突然改善,但这些变化的本质尚未得到充分阐释,而且也没有关于治疗师和患者如何解释这些变化的详细报告。本案例涉及一名61岁患有抑郁症、纤维肌痛和严重骨关节炎的女性,在接受了近一年的心理治疗后,在一次特定的心理治疗时段后实现了突然改善。作者讨论了患者和治疗师都认为在那个关键时段发生的、且他们认为促成了两年期间重度抑郁症缓解的认知变化的本质。本案例研究还探讨了药物和认知干预对突然改善可能产生的协同作用。对该案例的评论将关于突然改善的讨论与维德曼和佩里在20世纪80年代创建的一种名为心理动力生活叙事的干预措施联系起来,他们发现这种干预措施有时可以通过在抑郁危机期间重塑一个人的自我形象,尤其是与由疾病引发的绝望感相关的危机,从而迅速且显著地缓解症状。对产生导致即时、显著和持久改善的认知变化的干预措施本质的更多理解,可能会有助于开发出更有效的抑郁症及其他临床病症的治疗方法。