Department of Health and Kinesiology, Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, Georgia.
Department of Curriculum, Foundations, and Reading, Georgia Southern University, Statesboro, Georgia.
Anat Sci Educ. 2015 Sep-Oct;8(5):395-403. doi: 10.1002/ase.1489. Epub 2014 Sep 16.
"Desirable difficulties" is a theory from cognitive science used to promote learning in a variety of contexts. The basic premise is that creating a cognitively challenging environment at the learning acquisition phase, by actively engaging learners in the retrieval of to-be-learned materials, promotes long-term retention. In this study, the degree of desirable difficulties was varied to identify how cognitively challenging the learning acquisition phase must be to benefit university-level students' learning of anatomy concepts. This is important to investigate as applied studies of desirable difficulties are less frequent than laboratory-based studies and the implementation of this principle may need to be tailored to the specific field of study, such as anatomy. As such, a read-read-read-read (R-R-R-R) condition was compared to read-generate-read-generate (R-G-R-G) and read-test-read-test (R-T-R-T) conditions. The three conditions varied in terms of how effortful the retrieval task was during the learning acquisition phase. R-R-R-R required little effort because participants passively read the materials four times. R-G-R-G required some effort to generate a response as participants completed a word fragment task during the learning acquisition phase. R-T-R-T was thought to be most demanding as participants performed a free recall task twice during the learning phase. With regard to the absolute amount of anatomy information recalled, the R-T-R-T condition was superior at both immediate and delayed (one week) assessment points. Thus, instructors and learners of anatomy would benefit from embedding more free recall components, or self-testing, into university-level course work or study practices.
“期望困难”是认知科学中的一种理论,用于促进各种情境下的学习。其基本前提是,在学习获取阶段通过积极让学习者检索要学习的材料,创造一个认知上具有挑战性的环境,可以促进长期保留。在这项研究中,改变了期望困难的程度,以确定学习获取阶段的认知挑战性必须达到何种程度,才能有益于大学生学习解剖学概念。这一点很重要,因为与基于实验室的研究相比,期望困难的应用研究较少,而且这一原则的实施可能需要根据具体的学习领域(如解剖学)进行调整。因此,将“读-读-读-读(R-R-R-R)”条件与“读-生成-读-生成(R-G-R-G)”和“读-测试-读-测试(R-T-R-T)”条件进行了比较。这三种条件在学习获取阶段检索任务的费力程度上有所不同。R-R-R-R 只需很少的努力,因为参与者被动地阅读材料四次。R-G-R-G 需要一些努力来生成响应,因为参与者在学习获取阶段完成了一个单词片段任务。R-T-R-T 被认为是最费力的,因为参与者在学习阶段进行了两次自由回忆任务。关于回忆的解剖学信息的绝对数量,R-T-R-T 条件在即时和延迟(一周)评估点都具有优势。因此,解剖学的教师和学习者将受益于在大学水平的课程作业或学习实践中嵌入更多的自由回忆成分或自我测试。