Hauck Yvonne L, Kelly Georgina, Dragovic Milan, Butt Janice, Whittaker Pamela, Badcock Johanna C
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Curtin University, Western Australia, Australia; Department of Nursing and Midwifery Education and Research, King Edward Memorial Hospital, Subiaco, Western Australia, Australia.
Department of Nursing and Midwifery Education and Research, King Edward Memorial Hospital, Subiaco, Western Australia, Australia.
Midwifery. 2015 Jan;31(1):247-55. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2014.09.002. Epub 2014 Sep 16.
a cross sectional survey was undertaken to explore midwives' knowledge of, and attitudes towards, mental health disorders in childbearing women vis-à-vis their perceived mental health learning needs.
a 50.1% response rate included 238 midwives employed in the only public tertiary maternity hospital in Western Australia from March to June 2013.
The survey comprised a mixture of custom-designed questions and vignettes presenting various disorders. Only 37.6% of midwives felt well-equipped to support women, whilst 50.2% reported insufficient access to information. Demand was highest for education on: personality disorders (77.8%); the impact of childbearing on mental health disorders (74.2%); and skills for handling stress and aggression (57.8%). Knowledge scores were variable: on average eight out of a maximum 13 questions were answered correctly, but few (2.7%) answered more than 11 correctly, and 3.7% scored ≤4 correct. Across disorders, recognition from vignettes was highest for depression (93.9%), and lowest for schizophrenia (65.6%). Surprisingly, there were no associations between general knowledge scores and previous mental health experience, recent professional development, or access to information around mental health. The majority endorsed positive beliefs about midwives' role in mental health assessment, and belief in women's recovery (83.5%), however, cluster analysis of warmth and competence ratings revealed negative stereotyping of mental health disorders.
Midwives accept it is their role to assess the mental health status of women but many feel ill-equipped to do so and express a strong desire for further knowledge and skills across a range of perinatal mental health topics. Attitudes to recovery are positive but negative stereotypes exist; therefore awareness of potential bias is important to negate their influence on care.
Learning needs may change due to trends in clinical practice. Strategies are needed to recognise negative beliefs and to ensure education is responsive to local contexts.
开展了一项横断面调查,以探究助产士对育龄妇女心理健康障碍的了解程度、态度以及她们所认为的心理健康学习需求。
2013年3月至6月,西澳大利亚唯一一家公立三级妇产医院的238名助产士参与了调查,回复率为50.1%。
该调查包含定制问题和呈现各种障碍的案例。只有37.6%的助产士认为自己有足够能力支持妇女,而50.2%的助产士表示获取信息不足。对以下方面的教育需求最高:人格障碍(77.8%);生育对心理健康障碍的影响(74.2%);应对压力和攻击行为的技能(57.8%)。知识得分各不相同:最多13个问题平均答对8个,但很少有人(2.7%)答对超过11个,3.7%的人得分≤4个正确答案。在各种障碍中,案例识别方面对抑郁症的识别率最高(93.9%),对精神分裂症的识别率最低(65.6%)。令人惊讶的是,一般知识得分与以前的心理健康经验、近期专业发展或获取心理健康信息之间没有关联。大多数人认可助产士在心理健康评估中的积极作用以及对妇女康复的信念(83.5%),然而,对热情和能力评级的聚类分析显示对心理健康障碍存在负面刻板印象。
助产士认可评估妇女心理健康状况是他们的职责,但许多人觉得自己没有足够能力这样做,并表示强烈希望在一系列围产期心理健康主题方面获得更多知识和技能。对康复的态度是积极但存在负面刻板印象;因此,意识到潜在偏见对于消除其对护理的影响很重要。
学习需求可能因临床实践趋势而改变。需要采取策略来识别负面信念,并确保教育能够适应当地情况。