College of Medical & Dental Sciences, University of Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Department of Upper Gastrointestinal Surgery, University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, United Kingdom.
Int J Surg. 2014 Nov;12(11):1172-80. doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2014.09.008. Epub 2014 Sep 26.
Patients who develop significant dysphagia secondary to a potentially curable oesophageal cancer pose a significant clinical problem. Their nutritional needs can be met either by dietary supplementation, insertion of an oesophageal stent or through nasogastric or surgical feeding tube placement. We sought to determine whether, in patients about to start neo-adjuvant therapy prior to oesophagectomy, the use of oesophageal stent improves clinical outcomes. A best evidence topic in upper gastrointestinal surgery was written according to a structured protocol in order to answer this question. Two hundred and forty eight papers were found, of which eleven level III and one level IV study were considered to best address the clinical question. These indicate that whilst oesophageal stents do successfully relieve dysphagia throughout neoadjuvant therapy, they are not consistently associated with maintenance of, or improvement in, serum albumin or body weight. They are, however, commonly associated with stent migration and chest discomfort, both of which may frequently result in the need for stent removal or replacement. There is additional evidence within the manuscripts reviewed to demonstrate that the use of oesophageal stents in the neoadjuvant setting can lead to significant complications in a small proportion of patients which can compromise opportunity for curative surgery. The use of stents in this situation cannot be recommended.
对于因潜在可治愈的食管癌而出现明显吞咽困难的患者来说,这是一个重大的临床问题。他们的营养需求可以通过饮食补充、食管支架置入或鼻胃管或手术喂养管来满足。我们试图确定在接受新辅助治疗之前,食管支架的使用是否能改善临床结果。根据结构化方案,我们编写了一篇关于上消化道手术的最佳证据主题,以回答这个问题。共发现 248 篇论文,其中 11 篇为三级研究,1 篇为四级研究,被认为最能解决临床问题。这些研究表明,食管支架虽然在新辅助治疗期间成功缓解吞咽困难,但并不总是与血清白蛋白或体重的维持或改善相关。然而,支架移位和胸痛很常见,这两者都可能经常导致需要移除或更换支架。在回顾的文献中还有其他证据表明,食管支架在新辅助治疗中的使用可能会导致一小部分患者出现严重并发症,从而影响根治性手术的机会。因此,不建议在这种情况下使用支架。