Schrader Sarah A
Department of Anthropology, University of California, Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA, 95064.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2015 Feb;156(2):192-202. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.22637. Epub 2014 Oct 18.
Located 10 km south of the Third Cataract of the Nile River, the ancient city of Kerma was once capital to the second largest state in Africa. The Eastern Cemetery at Kerma (∼4 km east of city center) encompasses 80+ hectares and was used over a period of 1,500 years (3,200-1,500 BC). Excavated in the early 20th century by George Reisner, the cemetery contained an estimated 20,000-40,000 individuals. Reisner classified these burials into multiple categories, including chiefs and human sacrifices, based on burial position and grave goods. This study investigates the skeletal embodiment of social inequality by examining variation in entheseal severity between the Kerma burial classifications. Seventeen entheses were examined using the Hawkey and Merbs (1995) scoring method (n = 205 individuals); age, sex, and body size variables were considered by employing Mann-Whitney U tests and partial Spearman's correlations. This analysis suggests that significant differences in entheseal changes existed between select burial types. Specifically, "corridor sacrifices" had significantly higher rates of entheseal changes while "chiefs" and "subsidiary burials" had similar entheseal changes; furthermore, within these burial categories, males had higher entheseal scores despite body size controls. The elevated entheseal changes in the sacrificial burials may be due to an intensive agro-pastoral lifestyle or other demanding forms of manual labor. In conclusion, the disparity of entheseal markers between burial subgroups at Kerma might reflect a degree of social inequality within this state level society. This bioarchaeological research informs our understanding of socially-defined categories of persons as well as everyday life in Ancient Kerma.
凯尔迈古城位于尼罗河第三大瀑布以南10公里处,曾是非洲第二大国家的首都。凯尔迈东部墓地(位于市中心以东约4公里处)占地80多公顷,在1500年的时间里(公元前3200年至公元前1500年)一直被使用。该墓地于20世纪初由乔治·雷斯纳发掘,估计埋葬了2万至4万人。雷斯纳根据埋葬位置和随葬品将这些墓葬分为多个类别,包括首领墓葬和人祭墓葬。本研究通过考察凯尔迈墓葬分类之间附着点严重程度的差异,来探究社会不平等的骨骼体现。使用霍基和默布斯(1995年)的评分方法检查了17个附着点(n = 205人);通过曼-惠特尼U检验和偏斯皮尔曼相关性分析考虑了年龄、性别和体型变量。该分析表明,特定墓葬类型之间附着点变化存在显著差异。具体而言,“走廊祭品”的附着点变化率显著更高,而“首领”和“附属墓葬”的附着点变化相似;此外,在这些墓葬类别中,尽管控制了体型,男性的附着点分数更高。祭祀墓葬中附着点变化的增加可能是由于集约化农牧生活方式或其他繁重的体力劳动形式。总之,凯尔迈墓葬亚组之间附着点标记的差异可能反映了这个国家层面社会内部的一定程度的社会不平等。这项生物考古学研究有助于我们了解古代凯尔迈社会定义的人群类别以及日常生活。