Knudsen Michael L, Ludewig Paula M, Braman Jonathan P
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery University of Minnesota.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation University of Minnesota.
Iowa Orthop J. 2014;34:190-6.
The physical demands and high rates of musculoskeletal injury among practicing orthopaedic surgeons have been previously recognized in the literature. However, there is a paucity of data regarding musculoskeletal symptoms among resident orthopaedic surgeons. We sought to answer the following questions: (1) are there significant levels of musculoskeletal symptoms among resident orthopaedic surgeons?; (2) do residents attribute these symptoms to their work as surgeons?; and (3) is our survey instrument reliable enough for use in future investigations?
We developed an online, cross-sectional survey based on the previously validated Nordic Musculoskeletal Questionnaire and distributed it to 39 resident orthopaedic surgeons at our institution in 2011, with 82% responding. Fifteen participants repeated the survey to assess agreement and reliability between repeated administrations of the survey.
Significant levels of musculoskeletal symptoms were found in the resident surgeons, with the most common self-reported symptoms reported in the neck (59%), lower back (55%), upper back (35%), and shoulders (34%). Large proportions of these symptoms were self-reportedly attributed to the residents' work as a surgeon. Intrarater reliability revealed moderate to almost perfect agreement in nearly all repeated survey items.
Given that there are similar rates of musculoskeletal symptoms among our resident orthopedists and practicing orthopedists, more attention needs to be paid to the ergonomic and physical environments in which we are training the next generation of surgeons, especially when considering the extensive societal investment in training for these specialists.
骨科执业医师的体力需求以及肌肉骨骼损伤的高发生率此前已在文献中得到认可。然而,关于骨科住院医师肌肉骨骼症状的数据却很匮乏。我们试图回答以下问题:(1)骨科住院医师中是否存在显著程度的肌肉骨骼症状?(2)住院医师是否将这些症状归因于他们作为外科医生的工作?(3)我们的调查问卷对于未来的调查是否足够可靠?
我们基于先前经过验证的北欧肌肉骨骼问卷开发了一项在线横断面调查,并于2011年将其分发给我们机构的39名骨科住院医师,82%的人做出了回应。15名参与者重复进行了该调查,以评估重复调查之间的一致性和可靠性。
在住院医师中发现了显著程度的肌肉骨骼症状,自我报告最常见的症状出现在颈部(59%)、下背部(55%)、上背部(35%)和肩部(34%)。据自我报告,这些症状中有很大一部分归因于住院医师作为外科医生的工作。评分者内信度显示,几乎所有重复调查项目的一致性从中度到几乎完美。
鉴于我们的骨科住院医师和执业医师中肌肉骨骼症状的发生率相似,需要更加关注我们培训下一代外科医生的人体工程学和物理环境,尤其是考虑到社会对这些专科医生培训的大量投入时。