Kearns Malcolm D, Alvarez Jessica A, Seidel Natan, Tangpricha Vin
Division of Endocrinology, Metabolism and Lipids (MDK, JAA, NS, VT), Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia; and Section of Endocrinology (VT), Atlanta Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Atlanta, Georgia.
Am J Med Sci. 2015 Mar;349(3):245-62. doi: 10.1097/MAJ.0000000000000360.
Observational studies have linked vitamin D status and infectious disease. This association is supported by the presence of the vitamin D receptor and CYP27B1 in immune cells. This review aims to consolidate data from clinical trials that used vitamin D for the treatment or prevention of infectious disease.
The authors searched the term "(vitamin D OR ergocalciferol OR cholecalciferol OR vitamin D2 OR vitamin D3 OR calcitriol) AND (infection OR tuberculosis OR sepsis OR pneumonia)" with limits preset to manuscripts published in English and with human subjects. They identified controlled trials that measured infectious outcomes (eg, incidence and severity of disease, time to disease resolution or recurrence, measures of clinical improvement, mortality). Studies that used analog, topical or micronutrient formulations of vitamin D, assessed only vitamin D status or lacked a comparison group were excluded. The references from eligible manuscripts and from 2 recent reviews were scanned for additional manuscripts.
One thousand two hundred eighty-four manuscripts were identified with our search terms, with 60 papers still eligible after review of the title and abstract. Full review of these papers, their references and 2 related reviews yielded 38 manuscripts.
Although some prospective studies show positive results regarding vitamin D on infectious disease, several robust studies are negative. Factors such as high variability between studies, the difference in individual responsiveness to vitamin D and study designs that do not primarily investigate infectious outcomes may mask the effects of vitamin D on infections.
观察性研究已将维生素D状态与传染病联系起来。免疫细胞中存在维生素D受体和CYP27B1支持了这种关联。本综述旨在整合使用维生素D治疗或预防传染病的临床试验数据。
作者搜索了“(维生素D或麦角钙化醇或胆钙化醇或维生素D2或维生素D3或骨化三醇)和(感染或结核病或败血症或肺炎)”,并将范围限制为以英文发表且涉及人类受试者的手稿。他们确定了测量感染结果(如疾病的发病率和严重程度、疾病缓解或复发时间、临床改善指标、死亡率)的对照试验。使用维生素D类似物、局部制剂或微量营养素制剂、仅评估维生素D状态或缺乏对照组的研究被排除。对符合条件的手稿以及两篇近期综述的参考文献进行扫描,以查找其他手稿。
通过搜索词共识别出1284篇手稿,在对标题和摘要进行审查后,仍有60篇论文符合条件。对这些论文及其参考文献以及两篇相关综述进行全面审查后,得到38篇手稿。
尽管一些前瞻性研究显示维生素D对传染病有积极结果,但也有几项有力的研究结果为阴性。研究之间的高度变异性、个体对维生素D反应的差异以及并非主要研究感染结果的研究设计等因素,可能掩盖了维生素D对感染的影响。