Wang Jing, Gao Yan, Wang Qing-shan, Zhang Yan, Rong Li, Wang Jiu
Department of Oral Medicine, Affiliated Hospital of Binzhou Medical College. Binzhou 256603;China.E-mail:
Shanghai Kou Qiang Yi Xue. 2014 Aug;23(4):441-5.
To evaluate the cleaning effect of the C-shaped canal treated by manual K file and ProTaper rotary endodontic file combined with ultrasonic cleaning, and find a better cleaning program for the C-shaped root canal.
Fifty mandibular second molars were randomly divided into 5 groups: K file group, K file+ultrasonic rinsing group, ProTaper group, ProTaper+ultrasonic rinsing group and the control group. After initial shaping and cleaning, the mandibular second molars were soaked in formalin and stained. Under microscopy, the cleaning rate of necrotic tissue and cutting area were observed and analyzed. The data was processed with SPSS 17.0 software package.
The cleaning rates of the treated groups were significantly higher than that of the control group (P<0.05); In each treatment group, the cleaning rate of the apex was significantly lower than that of the crown and central part (P<0.05); The cutting score of ProTaper+ultrasonic cleaning group was lower than that of the other treatment groups; The cutting score of the K file+ultrasonic rinsing group was significantly lower than that of the K file group (P<0.05); The cutting score and cleaning rate were negatively correlated (r=-0.712, P=0.000 ), the linear regression was the cleaning rate =98.325-4.325 × wall cutting score (R=0.454, P<0.05).
In the process of shaping and cleaning of C-shaped canal, it is recommended that the ProTaper nickel-titanium rotary endodontic file should be chosen to clean the top of the taproot pipe and combined with ultrasonic rinsing to achieve better results.
评估手动K锉和ProTaper旋转根管锉联合超声冲洗处理C形根管的清洁效果,寻找更优的C形根管清洁方案。
将50颗下颌第二磨牙随机分为5组:K锉组、K锉+超声冲洗组、ProTaper组、ProTaper+超声冲洗组和对照组。初始预备和清洁后,将下颌第二磨牙浸泡于福尔马林中染色。在显微镜下观察并分析坏死组织的清洁率和切削面积。数据采用SPSS 17.0软件包处理。
各处理组的清洁率均显著高于对照组(P<0.05);各处理组中,根尖部的清洁率显著低于冠部和中部(P<0.05);ProTaper+超声冲洗组的切削评分低于其他处理组;K锉+超声冲洗组的切削评分显著低于K锉组(P<0.05);切削评分与清洁率呈负相关(r=-0.712,P=0.000),线性回归方程为清洁率=98.325-4.325×管壁切削评分(R=0.454,P<0.05)。
在C形根管预备和清洁过程中,建议选用ProTaper镍钛旋转根管锉清理主根管顶端并联合超声冲洗,以获得更好的效果。