Plodpai Yuvatiya, Atchariyasathian Viraporn, Khaimook Wandee
J Med Assoc Thai. 2014 Aug;97(8):850-5.
To compare the clinical characteristics of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) between the elderly and the younger patients.
The medical records of BPPV patients with positive testing result on the Dix-Hallpike or supine roll test between January 2002 and December 2012 at Songklanagarind hospital, Thailand were retrospectively reviewed.
Of the 951 BPPV patients, 595 patients were in the younger group (age < or =60-year-old, mean age = 46.9+/-8.9 years) and 356 patients were in the elderly group (age >60-year-old, mean age = 69.3+/-6. 7years). The most common etiology of BPPV was idiopathic. No significant difference was found regarding gender and semicircular canals that were involved in both groups. The most involved semicircular canal was the posterior canal. The most common described symptom of BPPV was vertigo. Patients in the elderly group were less likely to describe vertigo as the presenting symptom of BPPV compared to those in the younger group (OR = 0.22; 95% CI, 0. 12-0.41; p< 0. 001). The elderly group usually complained of imbalance and dizziness (OR = 15.83; 95% CI, 8.7-28.8; p<0. 001 and OR = 10.12; 95% CI, 5.23-19.59; p<0. 001, respectively). The duration of the symptom before diagnosis was longer in the elderly, when compared to the younger group (30 days, median; IQR = 7, 61 versus 5 days, median; IQR = 2, 7), respectively (p<0. 001). The ability to describe the trigger event precisely was less in the elderly group (63.8% versus 82.2%, p<0.001). The elderly group significantly underwent brain imaging studies more than the younger group (8.4% versus 3.5%, p = 0.02). Outcome of the treatment after the repositioning procedure was comparable in both groups (p = 0.58). Approximately 80% of patients in both groups had complete recovery from BPPV during their last visit.
Dizziness and imbalance were the common presenting symptoms of BPPV in the elderly. The younger patients tended to describe the classic symptom of vertigo that was specific to BPPV more precisely than the elderly. These may contribute to underestimate BPPV, do unnecessary brain imaging study, and take more time to get the correct diagnosis of BPP V among elderly patients.
比较老年和年轻良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)患者的临床特征。
回顾性分析2002年1月至2012年12月在泰国宋卡纳卡林医院经Dix-Hallpike或仰卧翻滚试验检测结果为阳性的BPPV患者的病历。
951例BPPV患者中,595例属于年轻组(年龄≤60岁,平均年龄=46.9±8.9岁),356例属于老年组(年龄>60岁,平均年龄=69.3±6.7岁)。BPPV最常见的病因是特发性。两组在性别和受累半规管方面未发现显著差异。最常受累的半规管是后半规管。BPPV最常见的症状是眩晕。与年轻组相比,老年组患者将眩晕描述为BPPV首发症状的可能性较小(OR=0.22;95%CI,0.12-0.41;p<0.001)。老年组通常主诉平衡失调和头晕(OR分别为15.83;95%CI,8.7-28.8;p<0.001和OR=10.12;95%CI,5.23-19.59;p<0.001)。与年轻组相比,老年组诊断前症状持续时间更长(分别为30天,中位数;IQR=7,61天与5天,中位数;IQR=2,7天)(p<0.001)。老年组准确描述诱发事件的能力较低(63.8%对82.2%,p<0.001)。老年组接受脑成像检查的比例显著高于年轻组(8.4%对3.5%,p=0.02)。复位治疗后的结果在两组中相当(p=0.58)。两组中约80%的患者在最后一次就诊时BPPV已完全恢复。
头晕和平衡失调是老年BPPV患者常见的首发症状。年轻患者比老年患者更倾向于准确描述BPPV特有的典型眩晕症状。这些可能导致低估老年患者的BPPV,进行不必要的脑成像检查,并需要更长时间才能正确诊断BPPV。