Carpentier S, van Gastel J, Schoenaers J, Carels C, Vander Poorten V, Coucke W, Verdonck A
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2014 Nov;51(6):651-7. doi: 10.1597/113-232.
Objective : The purpose of this longitudinal retrospective study was to evaluate transverse maxillary expansion after a Schuchardt or segmental posterior subapical maxillary osteotomy (SPSMO) in patients with cleft lip and palate (CLP). A second aim was to compare these data with data for adult patients without CLP who were receiving a surgical assisted rapid palatal expansion (SARPE). Method : The study group comprised 19 patients with CLP and a severe transversally collapsed maxilla who were treated with SPSMO followed by hyrax expansion at the University Hospitals Leuven. Dental casts of the 19 patients were analyzed before treatment, at maximum expansion, during orthodontic treatment, at the completion of orthodontic treatment. and 2 years after orthodontic treatment and were measured at the canine, premolar, and molar levels. Adult patients without CLP who were enrolled in a prospective study served as the control group. Results : Maxillary expansion within the study group was significantly greater (P < .05) at all measured levels compared with the maxillary arch before treatment. No significant relapse was measured in the study group 2 years after orthodontic treatment. When comparing the study and control groups, the only statistical difference was that canine expansion was significantly greater in the study group. Conclusion : SPSMO followed by maxillary expansion and orthodontic treatment is an appropriate treatment option to correct a severe transversally collapsed maxilla in patients with CLP. The overall treatment effect of SPSMO expansion is comparable with the effects of SARPE, although canine expansion was greater in the SPSMO group.
本纵向回顾性研究的目的是评估唇腭裂(CLP)患者在接受舒查特手术或节段性根尖下上颌骨截骨术(SPSMO)后的上颌横向扩展情况。第二个目的是将这些数据与接受外科辅助快速腭扩展(SARPE)的非CLP成年患者的数据进行比较。方法:研究组包括19例CLP且上颌严重横向塌陷的患者,他们在鲁汶大学医院接受了SPSMO手术,随后进行了Hyrax扩展。对这19例患者的牙模在治疗前、最大扩展时、正畸治疗期间、正畸治疗完成时以及正畸治疗后2年进行分析,并在尖牙、前磨牙和磨牙水平进行测量。参与一项前瞻性研究的非CLP成年患者作为对照组。结果:与治疗前的上颌牙弓相比,研究组在所有测量水平上的上颌扩展均显著更大(P <.05)。正畸治疗后2年,研究组未测量到明显的复发。在比较研究组和对照组时,唯一的统计学差异是研究组的尖牙扩展显著更大。结论:SPSMO术后进行上颌扩展和正畸治疗是纠正CLP患者严重横向塌陷上颌的合适治疗选择。SPSMO扩展的总体治疗效果与SARPE的效果相当,尽管SPSMO组的尖牙扩展更大。