Bebarta Vikhyat S, Pitotti Rebecca L, Boudreau Susan, Tanen David A
Medical Toxicology, San Antonio Military Medical Center, and Enroute Care Research Center, U.S. Army, Institute of Surgical Research, San Antonio, TX.
Acad Emerg Med. 2014 Nov;21(11):1203-11. doi: 10.1111/acem.12518.
Easily administrated cyanide antidotes are needed for first responders, military troops, and emergency department staff after cyanide exposure in mass casualty incidents or due to smoke inhalation during fires involving many victims. Hydroxocobalamin has proven to be an effective antidote, but cannot be given intramuscularly because the volume of diluent needed is too large. Thus, intraosseous (IO) infusion may be an alternative, as it is simple and has been recommended for the administration of other resuscitation drugs. The primary objective of this study was to compare the efficacy of IO delivery of hydroxocobalamin to intravenous (IV) injection for the management of acute cyanide toxicity in a well-described porcine model.
Twenty-four swine (45 to 55 kg) were anesthetized, intubated, and instrumented with continuous mean arterial pressure (MAP) and cardiac output monitoring. Cyanide was continuously infused until severe hypotension (50% of baseline MAP), followed by IO or IV hydroxocobalamin treatment. Animals were randomly assigned to receive IV (150 mg/kg) or IO (150 mg/kg) hydroxocobalamin and monitored for 60 minutes after start of antidotal infusion. The primary outcome measure was the change in MAP after antidotal treatment from onset of hypotension (time zero) to 60 minutes. A sample size of 12 animals per group was determined by group size analysis based on power of 80% to detect a one standard deviation of the mean MAP between the groups with an alpha of 0.05. Whole blood cyanide, lactate, pH, nitrotyrosine (nitric oxide marker) levels, cerebral and renal near infrared spectrometry (NIRS) oxygenation, and inflammatory markers were also measured. Repeated-measures analysis of variance was used to determine statistically significant changes between groups over time.
At baseline and at the point of hypotension, physiologic parameters were similar between groups. At the conclusion of the study, 10 out of 12 animals in the IV group and 10 out of 12 in IO group survived (p = 1.0). Both groups demonstrated a similar return to baseline MAP (p = 0.997). Cardiac output, oxygen saturation, and systemic vascular resistance were also found to be similar between groups (p > 0.4), and no difference was detected between bicarbonate, pH, and lactate levels (p > 0.8). Cyanide levels were undetectable after the hydroxocobalamin infusion throughout the study in both groups (p = 1.0). Cerebral and renal NIRS oxygenation decreased in parallel to MAP during cyanide infusion and increased after antidote infusion in both groups. Serum nitrotyrosine increased during cyanide infusion in all animals and then decreased in both study arms after hydroxocobalamin infusion (p > 0.5). Serum cytokines increased starting at cyanide infusion and no difference was detected between groups (tumor necrosis factor-α, interleukin [IL]-1β, IL-6, and IL-10).
The authors found no difference in the efficacy of IV versus IO hydroxocobalamin in the treatment of severe cyanide toxicity in a validated porcine model.
在大规模伤亡事件中氰化物暴露后,或在涉及众多受害者的火灾中因吸入烟雾导致氰化物中毒时,急救人员、军事人员和急诊科工作人员需要易于给药的氰化物解毒剂。羟钴胺已被证明是一种有效的解毒剂,但由于所需稀释液体积过大,不能进行肌肉注射。因此,骨内(IO)输注可能是一种替代方法,因为它操作简单,并且已被推荐用于其他复苏药物的给药。本研究的主要目的是在一个详细描述的猪模型中,比较骨内输注羟钴胺与静脉注射(IV)在治疗急性氰化物中毒方面的疗效。
24头猪(45至55千克)麻醉后插管,并配备连续平均动脉压(MAP)和心输出量监测设备。持续输注氰化物直至出现严重低血压(基线MAP的50%),然后进行骨内或静脉注射羟钴胺治疗。动物被随机分配接受静脉注射(150毫克/千克)或骨内注射(150毫克/千克)羟钴胺,并在解毒剂输注开始后监测60分钟。主要结局指标是从低血压发作(时间零点)到60分钟时解毒剂治疗后MAP的变化。根据80%的检验效能以检测两组间平均MAP的一个标准差,α为0.05,通过组间样本量分析确定每组12只动物的样本量。还测量了全血氰化物、乳酸、pH、硝基酪氨酸(一氧化氮标志物)水平、脑和肾近红外光谱(NIRS)氧合以及炎症标志物。采用重复测量方差分析来确定不同组随时间的统计学显著变化。
在基线和低血压时,两组间生理参数相似。在研究结束时,静脉注射组12只动物中有10只存活,骨内注射组12只中有10只存活(p = 1.0)。两组均显示出类似的恢复到基线MAP的情况(p = 0.997)。还发现两组间的心输出量、氧饱和度和全身血管阻力相似(p > 0.4),并且在碳酸氢盐、pH和乳酸水平方面未检测到差异(p > 0.8)。在整个研究过程中,两组在羟钴胺输注后均未检测到氰化物水平(p = 1.0)。在氰化物输注期间,脑和肾NIRS氧合与MAP平行下降,两组在解毒剂输注后均升高。在所有动物中,血清硝基酪氨酸在氰化物输注期间升高,然后在羟钴胺输注后在两个研究组中均下降(p > 0.5)。血清细胞因子从氰化物输注开始升高,两组间未检测到差异(肿瘤坏死因子-α、白细胞介素[IL]-1β、IL-6和IL-10)。
作者发现在一个经过验证的猪模型中,静脉注射与骨内注射羟钴胺在治疗严重氰化物中毒方面的疗效没有差异。