French Simon D, Bennell Kim L, Nicolson Philippa J A, Hodges Paul W, Dobson Fiona L, Hinman Rana S
University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, and Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2015 May;67(6):809-16. doi: 10.1002/acr.22518.
To establish priority key messages for patients with osteoarthritis (OA).
A Delphi survey and priority pairwise ranking activity was conducted. Participants included 51 OA experts from 13 countries and 9 patients (consumers) living with hip and/or knee OA. During 3 Delphi rounds, the panel of experts and consumers rated recommendations extracted from clinical guidelines and provided additional statements they considered important. When ≥70% of panel members agreed a statement was "essential," it was retained for the next Delphi round. The final list of essential statements was reviewed by a consumer focus group and statements were modified for clarity if required. Finally, a priority pairwise ranking activity determined the rank order of the list of essential messages.
Eighty-five experts and 15 consumers were invited to participate; 51 experts and 9 consumers completed round 1 of the Delphi survey, and 43 experts and 8 consumers completed the final priority ranking activity. From an original list of 114 statements, 21 statements were rated as essential. Most statements (n = 17) related to nondrug treatment approaches for OA. Study limitations included that >50% of the panel comprised of physical therapists lead to high rankings of exercise and physical activity statements and also that only English-language statements were considered.
OA experts and consumers have identified and prioritized 21 key patient messages about OA. These messages may be used to inform the content of consumer educational materials to ensure patients are educated about the most important aspects of OA and its management.
为骨关节炎(OA)患者确定优先重点信息。
开展了一项德尔菲调查和优先两两排序活动。参与者包括来自13个国家的51名OA专家以及9名患有髋部和/或膝部OA的患者(消费者)。在3轮德尔菲调查中,专家小组和消费者对从临床指南中提取的建议进行评分,并提供他们认为重要的其他陈述。当≥70%的小组成员认为某一陈述“至关重要”时,该陈述将保留到下一轮德尔菲调查。最终的重要陈述清单由一个消费者焦点小组进行审查,如有需要,会对陈述进行修改以使其更清晰。最后,通过优先两两排序活动确定重要信息清单的排序。
邀请了85名专家和15名消费者参与;51名专家和9名消费者完成了德尔菲调查的第一轮,43名专家和8名消费者完成了最终的优先排序活动。从最初的114条陈述清单中,有21条陈述被评为至关重要。大多数陈述(n = 17)与OA的非药物治疗方法有关。研究局限性包括:超过50%的专家小组由物理治疗师组成,导致锻炼和身体活动陈述的排名较高,并且仅考虑了英文陈述。
OA专家和消费者已经确定并对21条关于OA的关键患者信息进行了优先排序。这些信息可用于指导消费者教育材料的内容,以确保患者了解OA及其管理的最重要方面。