Mac Giolla Phadraig Caoimhin, Nunn June, Dougall Alison, O'Neill Eunan, McLoughlin Jacinta, Guerin Suzanne
Department of Public and Child Dental Health, Dublin Dental University Hospital and Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Public Health, Oxfordshire County Council, Oxford, Oxfordshire, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2014 Nov 24;9(11):e113393. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0113393. eCollection 2014.
This study aimed to generate prioritised goals for oral health services for people with disabilities as a first step in meeting the need for evidence based oral health services for people with disabilities in Ireland.
The study used a three round modified e-Delphi method, involving dental service professionals and people with disabilities or their representatives, in Ireland. Three rounds were completed online using SurveyMonkey. Round 1 asked: "List what you think dental services for people with disabilities in Ireland should be like." Items for subsequent rounds were generated from responses to Round 1. Round 2 and Round 3 used 5 point Likert scales to rank these items by priority: from No Priority (1) to Top Priority (5). Consensus was achieved on each item where at least 80% of respondents considered an item either High or Top Priority. A consensus meeting concluded the process.
Sixty-one panelists started and 48 completed the survey. The Delphi panel agreed on level of priority for 69 items and generated 16 consensus statements. These statements covered a range of topics such as access to care, availability of information and training, quality of care, dental treatment and cost. A recurrent theme relating to the appropriateness of care to individual need arose across topics suggesting a need to match service delivery according to the individual's needs, wants and expectations rather than the disability type/diagnosis based service which predominates today.
This process produced a list of prioritised goals for dental services for people with disabilities. This creates a foundation for building evidence-based service models for people with disabilities in Ireland.
本研究旨在为残疾人士的口腔健康服务制定优先目标,作为满足爱尔兰残疾人士循证口腔健康服务需求的第一步。
该研究采用三轮改进的电子德尔菲法,参与者包括爱尔兰的牙科服务专业人员以及残疾人士或其代表。三轮调查均通过SurveyMonkey在线完成。第一轮询问:“列出你认为爱尔兰残疾人士的牙科服务应该是怎样的。”后续轮次的项目根据第一轮的回答生成。第二轮和第三轮使用5点李克特量表按优先级对这些项目进行排序:从无优先级(1)到最高优先级(5)。当至少80%的受访者认为某个项目为高优先级或最高优先级时,该项目达成共识。最后召开了一次共识会议。
61名小组成员开始参与调查,48人完成了调查。德尔菲小组就69个项目的优先级别达成一致,并生成了16条共识声明。这些声明涵盖了一系列主题,如获得护理、信息和培训的可及性、护理质量、牙科治疗和费用等。在各个主题中都出现了一个与根据个体需求提供适当护理相关的反复出现的主题,这表明需要根据个体的需求、愿望和期望来匹配服务提供,而不是像如今占主导地位的基于残疾类型/诊断的服务。
这一过程产生了一份残疾人士牙科服务的优先目标清单。这为在爱尔兰建立残疾人士循证服务模式奠定了基础。