Aelbrecht Karolien, Rimondini Michela, Bensing Jozien, Moretti Francesca, Willems Sara, Mazzi Mariangela, Fletcher Ian, Deveugele Myriam
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Department of Family Medicine and Primary Health Care, Ghent University Hospital - 6K3, De Pintelaan 185, 9000, Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Public Health and Community Medicine, University of Verona, Verona, Italy.
Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2015 Oct;20(4):873-84. doi: 10.1007/s10459-014-9569-6. Epub 2014 Nov 27.
Good doctor-patient communication may lead to better compliance, higher patient satisfaction, and finally, better health. Although the social variance in how physicians and patients communicate is clearly demonstrated, little is known about what patients with different educational attainments actually prefer in doctor-patient communication. In this study we describe patients' perspective in doctor-patient communication according to their educational level, and to what extent these perspectives lean towards the expert opinion on doctor-patient communication. In a multi-center study (Belgium, The Netherlands, UK and Italy), focus group discussions were organised using videotaped medical consultations. A mixed methods approach was used to analyse the data. Firstly, a difference in perspective in communication style was found between the lower educated participants versus the middle and higher educated participants. Secondly, lower educated participants referred positively most to aspects related to the affective/emotional area of the medical consultation, followed by the task-oriented/problem-focused area. Middle and higher educated participants positively referred most to the task-oriented/problem-focused area. The competency of the physician was an important category of communication for all participants, independent of social background. The results indicate that the preferences of lower educated participants lean more towards the expert opinion in doctor-patient communication than the middle and higher educated participants. Patients' educational level seems to influence their perspective on communication style and should be taken into account by physicians. Further quantitative research is needed to confirm these results.
良好的医患沟通可能会带来更好的依从性、更高的患者满意度,最终实现更优的健康状况。尽管医患沟通方式上的社会差异已得到明确证实,但对于不同教育程度的患者在医患沟通中实际偏好什么,我们却知之甚少。在本研究中,我们根据患者的教育水平描述了他们在医患沟通中的观点,以及这些观点在多大程度上倾向于医患沟通方面的专家意见。在一项多中心研究(比利时、荷兰、英国和意大利)中,通过对医疗咨询进行录像组织了焦点小组讨论。采用混合方法对数据进行分析。首先,发现受教育程度较低的参与者与受教育程度中等和较高的参与者在沟通方式上存在观点差异。其次,受教育程度较低的参与者对医疗咨询中情感/情绪方面的相关内容提及最多,其次是任务导向/问题聚焦方面。受教育程度中等和较高的参与者对任务导向/问题聚焦方面提及最多。医生的能力对所有参与者来说都是一个重要的沟通类别,与社会背景无关。结果表明,在医患沟通中,受教育程度较低的参与者的偏好比受教育程度中等和较高的参与者更倾向于专家意见。患者的教育水平似乎会影响他们对沟通方式的看法,医生应予以考虑。需要进一步的定量研究来证实这些结果。