Hysi Ilir, Kipnis Eric, Fayoux Pierre, Copin Marie-Christine, Zawadzki Christophe, Jashari Ramadan, Hubert Thomas, Ung Alexandre, Ramon Philippe, Jude Brigitte, Wurtz Alain
Cardiac and Thoracic Surgery Division, Lille University Teaching Hospital, CHU Lille, Lille, France IMPRT-IFR 114, EA 2693, Lille University Medical School, UDSL, Université Lille Nord de France, Lille, France.
Department of Surgical Critical Care, Lille University Teaching Hospital, CHU Lille, Lille, France.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2015 Feb;47(2):e54-61. doi: 10.1093/ejcts/ezu444. Epub 2014 Dec 4.
Results of tracheal transplantation have been disappointing due to of ischaemia and rejection. It has been experimentally demonstrated that results of tracheal autograft/allograft transplantation were correlated with both graft length and revascularization method. Recently, we demonstrated that heterotopic epithelium-denuded-cryopreserved tracheal allograft (TA) displayed satisfactory immune tolerance. We aimed at evaluating the results of such allografts in orthotopic transplantation according to graft length and prior heterotopic or single-stage orthotopic revascularization in a rabbit model.
Twenty New Zealand rabbits were used. Six females served as donors. Tracheal mucosa was mechanically peeled off and then the TAs were cryopreserved. Male recipients were divided into three groups receiving: (i) long TA segment with prior heterotopic revascularization (10-12 tracheal rings, n = 3); (ii) average TA segment with single-stage orthotopic revascularization (6-8 tracheal rings, n = 4); (iii) short TA segment with single-stage orthotopic revascularization (4-5 tracheal rings, n = 7). No immunosuppressive therapy was administered. Grafts were assessed bronchoscopically and upon death or sacrifice by macroscopic evaluation, histology and immunohistochemical staining for apoptosis.
Four animals were sacrificed from Day 33 to Day 220. The survival time of other recipients was 0-47 days (mean 19.6 ± 16.7 days). Aside from three animals that died from complications, all TA segments had satisfactory stiffness, were well vascularized, showed varying levels of neoangiogenesis and inflammatory infiltration devoid of lymphocytes, and showed evidence of only low levels of apoptosis. Varying degrees of fibroblastic proliferation originating from the lamina propria were observed in the lumen of all TAs and evolved over time into collagenized fibrosis in animals surviving over 45 days. Likewise, cartilage tracheal rings exhibited central calcification deposits, which started on Day 16 and increased over time. Epithelial regeneration was constantly observed. Intense fibroblastic proliferation led to stenosis in all animals from Groups (i) and (ii) but only one of seven animals from Group (iii).
Our results suggest that short segments of epithelium-denuded-cryopreserved TA may be reliable for tracheal transplantation in the rabbit model without problems related to graft stiffness or immune rejection. Before considering clinical applications, investigations should be conducted in larger mammals.
由于缺血和排斥反应,气管移植的结果一直不尽人意。实验证明,气管自体移植/同种异体移植的结果与移植物长度和血管重建方法均相关。最近,我们证明了异位去上皮冷冻保存的气管同种异体移植物(TA)表现出令人满意的免疫耐受性。我们旨在根据移植物长度以及在兔模型中先前的异位或单阶段原位血管重建情况,评估此类同种异体移植物在原位移植中的结果。
使用20只新西兰兔。6只雌性作为供体。机械剥脱气管黏膜,然后将TA冷冻保存。雄性受体分为三组,分别接受:(i)长TA段并预先进行异位血管重建(10 - 12个气管环,n = 3);(ii)平均TA段并进行单阶段原位血管重建(6 - 8个气管环,n = 4);(iii)短TA段并进行单阶段原位血管重建(4 - 5个气管环,n = 7)。未给予免疫抑制治疗。通过支气管镜检查以及在死亡或处死后进行大体评估、组织学检查和凋亡的免疫组化染色来评估移植物。
从第33天到第220天处死了4只动物。其他受体的存活时间为0 - 47天(平均19.6±16.7天)。除3只死于并发症的动物外,所有TA段均具有令人满意的硬度,血管化良好,显示出不同程度的新生血管形成和无淋巴细胞的炎性浸润,并且仅显示出低水平凋亡的证据。在所有TA段的管腔内均观察到源自固有层的不同程度的成纤维细胞增殖,并在存活超过45天的动物中随时间演变为胶原化纤维化。同样,气管软骨环出现中央钙化沉积,始于第16天并随时间增加。持续观察到上皮再生。强烈的成纤维细胞增殖导致第(i)组和第(ii)组的所有动物出现狭窄,但第(iii)组的7只动物中只有1只出现狭窄。
我们的结果表明,短段去上皮冷冻保存的TA在兔模型中进行气管移植可能是可靠的,不存在与移植物硬度或免疫排斥相关的问题。在考虑临床应用之前,则应在更大的哺乳动物中进行研究。