Shuaib Waqas, Hashmi Mariyam, Vijayasarathi Arvind, Arunkumar Jay, Tiwana Sabeen, Khosa Faisal
Department of Radiology and Imaging Sciences, Emory University Hospital, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Dow International Medical College, DUHS, Karachi, Pakistan.
Clin Med Res. 2015 Dec;13(3-4):112-6. doi: 10.3121/cmr.2014.1249. Epub 2014 Dec 8.
Facial computed tomography (CT) is often performed in the emergency department as a part of the diagnostic workup for patients presenting with the signs and symptoms of dentoalveolar abscess (DA). This investigation evaluated the diagnostic yield of the facial CT and its effects on management change in patients suspected of DA. Furthermore, we assessed secondary consequences of routine facial CT use in this population by using turn-around time (TAT), cost, and radiation exposure as the key parameters.
We retrospectively reviewed records of suspected DA patients over a 5-year period, from June 2008 to June 2013. TAT was calculated for patients from the time the examination was ordered by the emergency department physician, to the time the report was finalized by the attending radiologist. Effective radiation dose for facial CT was calculated by multiplying dose length product by the standard conversion coefficient K (K = 0.0021 mSv/mGy x cm). CT cost was included for reference but was not analyzed extensively due to the lack of standardization of costs across the various institutions.
Our investigation consisted of 117 patients; 75 males of average age 41 (±12) years and 42 females of average age 44 (±17) years. Out of the total 117 patients that underwent CT for the suspicion of a simple DA, only a single individual (0.85%) underwent a management change. Mean TAT of facial CT was 110 (±63) minutes, and a median TAT was 87 (±71) minutes. Average effective radiation dose for a facial CT was 2.4 (±0.4) mSv. Approximate estimated cost of a contrast enhanced facial CT was $253 and non-contrast facial CT was $209.
Our study shows that routine use of facial CT has a very limited diagnostic value in the workup of simple DA and rarely results in management change. The overall impact on patient management is miniscule in the context of prolonged TAT, radiation exposure, and adding to the rising medical costs.
面部计算机断层扫描(CT)常在急诊科进行,作为对出现牙槽脓肿(DA)体征和症状患者诊断检查的一部分。本研究评估了面部CT的诊断价值及其对疑似DA患者治疗方案改变的影响。此外,我们以周转时间(TAT)、成本和辐射暴露为关键参数,评估了在该人群中常规使用面部CT的次要后果。
我们回顾性分析了2008年6月至2013年6月期间5年内疑似DA患者的记录。计算患者从急诊科医生开出检查单到主治放射科医生完成报告的TAT。面部CT的有效辐射剂量通过剂量长度乘积乘以标准转换系数K(K = 0.0021 mSv/mGy x cm)来计算。CT成本仅供参考,但由于各机构成本缺乏标准化,未进行广泛分析。
我们的研究包括117例患者;75例男性,平均年龄41(±12)岁,42例女性,平均年龄44(±17)岁。在总共117例因疑似单纯DA而接受CT检查的患者中,只有1例(0.85%)治疗方案发生改变。面部CT的平均TAT为110(±63)分钟,中位TAT为87(±71)分钟。面部CT的平均有效辐射剂量为2.4(±0.4)mSv。增强面部CT的估计成本约为253美元,非增强面部CT为209美元。
我们的研究表明,在单纯DA的检查中常规使用面部CT的诊断价值非常有限,很少导致治疗方案改变。在TAT延长、辐射暴露以及医疗成本不断上升的背景下,对面患者治疗的总体影响微乎其微。