Hospital Universitario Puerta de Hierro Majadahonda.
J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2014 Nov 8;15(6):4663. doi: 10.1120/jacmp.v15i6.4663.
The purpose of this study was to quantify the systematic and random errors for various disease sites when daily MVCT scans are acquired, and to analyze alterna- tive off-line verification protocols (OVP) with respect to the patient setup accuracy achieved. Alignment data from 389 patients (9,418 fractions) treated at ten differ- ent anatomic sites with daily image-guidance (IG) on a helical tomotherapy unit were analyzed. Moreover, six OVP were retrospectively evaluated. For each OVP, the frequency of the residual setup errors and additional margins required were calculated for the treatment sessions without image guidance. The magnitude of the three-dimensional vector displacement and its frequency were evaluated for all OVP. From daily IG, the main global systematic error was in the vertical direction (4.4-9.4 mm), and all rotations were negligible (less than 0.5°) for all anatomic sites. The lowest systematic and random errors were found for H&N and brain patients. All OVP were effective in reducing the mean systematic error to less than 1 mm and 0.2° in all directions and roll corrections for almost all treatment sites. The treatment margins needed to adapt the residual errors should be increased by 2-5 mm for brain and H&N, around 8 mm in the vertical direction for the other anatomic sites, and up to 19 mm in the longitudinal direction for abdomen patients. Almost 70% of the sessions presented a setup error of 3 mm for OVPs with an imaging frequency above 50%. Only for brain patients it would be feasible to apply an OVP because the residual setup error could be compensated for with a slight margin increase. However, daily imaging should be used for anatomic sites of difficult immobilization and/or large interfraction movement.
本研究旨在量化在每天获取 MVCT 扫描时各种病变部位的系统误差和随机误差,并分析替代的离线验证方案(OVP)与患者摆位精度之间的关系。对 10 个不同解剖部位的 389 例患者(9418 个分次)的摆位数据进行了分析,这些患者在螺旋断层放疗设备上每天接受图像引导(IG)治疗。此外,还回顾性地评估了六种 OVP。对于每种 OVP,计算了没有图像引导的治疗疗程中残余摆位误差的频率和所需的额外边界。还评估了所有 OVP 的三维矢量位移幅度及其频率。从每天的 IG 中,主要的全局系统误差在垂直方向(4.4-9.4mm),所有旋转角度均可以忽略不计(小于 0.5°),适用于所有解剖部位。H&N 和脑部患者的系统误差和随机误差最低。所有 OVP 都能有效地将平均系统误差降低到 1mm 以内,在所有方向和滚转方向的误差校正都在 0.2°以内,几乎所有治疗部位都可以进行。为了适应残余误差,需要将治疗边界增加 2-5mm 用于脑部和 H&N,对于其他解剖部位,在垂直方向上需要增加约 8mm 的边界,对于腹部患者,在纵向方向上需要增加 19mm 的边界。在 OVP 的图像采集频率高于 50%的情况下,约 70%的治疗疗程的摆位误差为 3mm。只有对于脑部患者,应用 OVP 才是可行的,因为可以通过轻微增加边界来补偿残余的摆位误差。然而,对于难以固定和/或分次间运动较大的解剖部位,应该每天进行成像。