Hu L B, Huang Z G, Wei H Y, Wang W, Ren A, Xu Y Y
1 Department of Radiology, China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, China.
Br J Radiol. 2015 Feb;88(1046):20140508. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20140508. Epub 2014 Dec 11.
To investigate the accuracy of using CT and MRI to characterize lesions of osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH).
Coronal CT and MRI scans were performed on 30 femoral head specimens collected from 23 patients who had undertaken hip arthroplasty owing to ONFH. The results were compared with findings from coronal sectional gross specimens. Two radiologists independently measured the volume of necrotic lesions from CT and MR images using computer software, and the results were averaged. The volume of specimens' necrotic lesion was measured using the water displacement method.
There was a high degree of consistency between CT, MRI and the coronal sectional gross specimen on the location, shape and spatial structure of lesions. Differences of the lesion volume measured from CT and MR images were not statistically significant between two radiologists. The necrotic lesion volumes measured from CT and MR images and gross specimens were 22.07 ±5.35, 22.21 ± 5.15 and 21.12 ±4.96 cm(3), respectively, and the differences were not statistically significant (F = 0.396; p = 0.674).
For patients with ONFH in Association Research Circulation Osseous stage III or above, CT and MRI can accurately display the characterization of lesion.
The size and location of necrotic lesions are major factors associated with femoral head collapse. CT is superior to MRI in identifying subchondral fracture. CT can help diagnose and predict the prognosis of ONFH.
探讨使用CT和MRI对股骨头坏死(ONFH)病变进行特征性描述的准确性。
对23例因ONFH接受髋关节置换术患者的30个股骨头标本进行冠状位CT和MRI扫描。将结果与冠状位断面大体标本的结果进行比较。两名放射科医生使用计算机软件独立测量CT和MR图像上坏死病变的体积,并将结果取平均值。使用排水法测量标本坏死病变的体积。
CT、MRI与冠状位断面大体标本在病变的位置、形状和空间结构方面具有高度一致性。两名放射科医生测量的CT和MR图像上病变体积的差异无统计学意义。CT和MR图像以及大体标本测量的坏死病变体积分别为22.07±5.35、22.21±5.15和21.12±4.96cm³,差异无统计学意义(F = 0.396;p = 0.674)。
对于国际骨循环研究学会(ARCO)分期为III期及以上的ONFH患者,CT和MRI能够准确显示病变特征。
坏死病变的大小和位置是与股骨头塌陷相关的主要因素。在识别软骨下骨折方面,CT优于MRI。CT有助于ONFH的诊断和预后预测。