Wei Qiushi, He Wei, Zhang Qingwen, Chen Zhenqiu, Zheng Yuesheng, Lin Tianye
Joint Center, Third Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, Guangzhou Guangdong, 510378, P.R.China.
Guangdong Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine Orthopedics and Traumatology, Guangzhou Guangdong, 510378, P.R.China.
Zhongguo Xiu Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2021 Sep 15;35(9):1105-1110. doi: 10.7507/1002-1892.202103221.
To explore the different imaging manifestations of osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH) and their correlation with the occurrence of pain during the peri-collapse period.
The 372 patients (624 hips) with ONFH in the peri-collapse stage who were admitted between December 2016 and October 2019 and met the selection criteria were selected as the research objects. Among them, there were 270 males and 102 females, with an average age of 35.3 years (mean, 15-65 years). There were 120 cases of unilateral hip and 252 cases of bilateral hips. There were 39 cases (39 hips) of traumatic ONFH, 196 cases (346 hips) of hormonal ONFH, 102 cases (178 hips) of alcoholic ONFH, and 35 cases (61 hips) of idiopathic ONFH. Among them, there were 482 hips with pain symptoms and 142 hips without pain. The pain duration was less than 3 months in 212 hips, 3-6 months in 124 hips, 6-12 months in 117 hips, and more than 12 months in 29 hips. According to the Association Research Circulation Osseous (ARCO) staging, the ONFH was rated as stage Ⅱ in 325 hips and stage Ⅲ in 299 hips. The patients were grouped according to ONFH etiology and ARCO staging, and hip joint pain and X-ray film (crescent sign and cystic changes), CT (subchondral bone fractures and cystic changes), and MRI (bone marrow edema, joint effusion, and subchondral hypointensity zone) were compared. Spearman rank correlation was used to determine the correlation between ONFH pain duration and X-ray film, CT, and MRI imaging manifestations.
There were significant differences ( <0.05) between ONFH patients with different etiologies in crescent sign on X-ray film, subchondral bone fracture on CT, and joint effusion on MRI. And there were significant differences ( <0.05) between ONFH patients with different ARCO stages in hip pain duration and all imaging manifestations. Correlation analysis showed that the pain duration of ONFH patients was correlated with all imaging manifestations ( <0.05). The cystic change on CT was correlated with the subchondral hypointensity zone and joint effusion grade on MRI, and subchondral hypointensity zone and joint effusion grade on MRI were also correlated ( <0.05).
The cystic changes, subchondral hypointensity zone, and joint effusion are closely related to the collapse of the femoral head and hip pain in patients with ONFH in the peri-collapse stage. The above-mentioned signals in stage Ⅱ ONFH indicate the instability of the femoral head, which is to predict the development of ONFH and the rational choice of hip-preserving treatment methods provides a basis.
探讨股骨头坏死(ONFH)在塌陷前期的不同影像学表现及其与疼痛发生的相关性。
选取2016年12月至2019年10月收治的处于塌陷前期且符合入选标准的372例ONFH患者(624髋)作为研究对象。其中,男性270例,女性102例,平均年龄35.3岁(范围15 - 65岁)。单侧髋120例,双侧髋252例。创伤性ONFH 39例(39髋),激素性ONFH 196例(346髋),酒精性ONFH 102例(178髋),特发性ONFH 35例(61髋)。其中有疼痛症状的髋482个,无疼痛的髋142个。疼痛持续时间小于3个月的髋212个,3 - 6个月的髋124个,6 - 12个月的髋117个,大于12个月的髋29个。根据骨循环研究协会(ARCO)分期,ONFH处于Ⅱ期的髋325个,Ⅲ期的髋299个。根据ONFH病因及ARCO分期对患者进行分组,比较髋关节疼痛情况及X线片(新月征和囊性改变)、CT(软骨下骨骨折和囊性改变)、MRI(骨髓水肿、关节积液和软骨下低信号区)表现。采用Spearman等级相关分析确定ONFH疼痛持续时间与X线片、CT及MRI影像学表现之间的相关性。
不同病因的ONFH患者在X线片新月征、CT软骨下骨骨折及MRI关节积液方面存在显著差异(<0.05)。不同ARCO分期的ONFH患者在髋关节疼痛持续时间及所有影像学表现方面存在显著差异(<0.05)。相关性分析显示,ONFH患者疼痛持续时间与所有影像学表现均相关(<0.05)。CT上的囊性改变与MRI上的软骨下低信号区及关节积液分级相关,MRI上的软骨下低信号区与关节积液分级也相关(<0.05)。
囊性改变、软骨下低信号区及关节积液与ONFH塌陷前期患者的股骨头塌陷及髋关节疼痛密切相关。Ⅱ期ONFH的上述信号提示股骨头不稳定,为预测ONFH的发展及保髋治疗方法的合理选择提供了依据。