Van Hoeyweghen R, Mullie A, Bossaert L
Department of Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine, University Antwerp UIA, Belgium.
Resuscitation. 1989;17 Suppl:S137-47; discussion S199-206. doi: 10.1016/0300-9572(89)90098-1.
CPR should be initiated in any patient who has a cardiac arrest. This might improve overall outcome but implies that CPR is started in patients without any virtual chance for long-term survival (LTS). The aim of this study is, by analysing retrospectively 2713 out-of-hospital cardiac arrests (CA), to identify indices which might be of help in the decision making to continue or to discontinue CPR. In an important number of unsuccessful CPR attempts ALS-time did not exceed 20 min. This occurred more frequently in subgroups where limited chances of LTS are expected on clinical grounds. The decision to cease CPR might have been based on other clinical and/or ethical parameters which were not recorded in the registry. This behavior results in a "self-fulfilling prophecy". A subset of patients with limited chances for LTS (0/405) can be identified: patients in electromechanical dissociation (EMD) or asystole on arrival of the mobile intensive care unit (MICU) team, without pupil reaction to light during CPR and with inefficient cardiac massage by the MICU (405/2713). Other patients in EMD or asystole without pupil reaction to light during CPR (1373/2713) but with efficient ECC should be resuscitated for more than 30 min, especially if the patient is gasping during CPR (LTS 27/1373). Patients in EMD or asystole on arrival of the MICU with pupil reaction to light during CPR (236/2713) should have an ALS-time of at least 45 min (LTS 42/236). Cardiac arrests in ventricular fibrillation (VF) (699/2713) should be resuscitated for at least 45 min, especially when gasping during CPR (LTS 119/699).
任何发生心脏骤停的患者都应立即进行心肺复苏(CPR)。这可能会改善总体预后,但这意味着要对那些几乎没有长期生存(LTS)机会的患者进行心肺复苏。本研究的目的是,通过对2713例院外心脏骤停(CA)进行回顾性分析,确定有助于决定继续或停止心肺复苏的指标。在大量心肺复苏未成功的案例中,高级生命支持(ALS)时间未超过20分钟。这种情况在基于临床理由预期长期生存机会有限的亚组中更为常见。停止心肺复苏的决定可能基于登记中未记录的其他临床和/或伦理参数。这种行为导致了一种“自我实现的预言”。可以识别出一组长期生存机会有限的患者(0/405):移动重症监护病房(MICU)团队到达时处于电机械分离(EMD)或心搏停止状态,心肺复苏期间瞳孔对光无反应且MICU进行的心脏按压无效的患者(405/2713)。其他在心肺复苏期间处于EMD或心搏停止状态且瞳孔对光无反应(1373/2713)但心肺复苏有效的患者应进行超过30分钟的复苏,尤其是如果患者在心肺复苏期间有喘息(长期生存27/1373)。MICU到达时处于EMD或心搏停止状态且心肺复苏期间瞳孔对光有反应的患者(236/2713)应进行至少45分钟的ALS(长期生存42/236)。心室颤动(VF)导致的心脏骤停(699/2713)应进行至少45分钟的复苏,尤其是在心肺复苏期间有喘息的情况下(长期生存119/699)。