Dutch Growth Research Foundation, Westzeedijk 106, 3016 AH, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2015 Sep;24(9):1091-101. doi: 10.1007/s00787-014-0662-4. Epub 2014 Dec 19.
Information on behavior of children with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS) and the effect of growth hormone (GH) treatment is scarce. Parents report less problem behavior during GH treatment. Forty-two pre-pubertal children, aged 3.5-14 years were studied in a randomized controlled GH trial (RCT) during 2 years, followed by a longitudinal study during 8 years of GH treatment. Behavior was measured annually by the Developmental Behavior Checklist for children with intellectual disability (DBC) and a Dutch questionnaire to evaluate social behavioral problems in children, the Children's Social Behavior Questionnaire (CSBQ). Problem behavior measured by the DBC in children with PWS was similar compared to peers with comparable intellectual disability. Scores on 'Social disabilities' subscale were however significantly higher compared to the DBC total score (p < 0.01). A lower IQ was associated with more self-absorbed behavior, more communication problems and more problem behavior in general. Problem behavior measured by the CSBQ was similar compared to peers with a comparable intellectual disability, but children with PWS scored significantly higher on the 'Not tuned', 'Understanding', and 'Stereotyped' subscales than the CSBQ total score (p < 0.05 for all subscales and p = 0.001 for the 'Not tuned'-subscale). There were no significant effects of GH treatment during the RCT and 8 years of GH treatment. Children with PWS showed similar problem behavior as a reference population with a comparable intellectual disability. Social problems were the most pronounced within-problem behavior in PWS. In contrast to our expectations and parents reports, our study shows no improvement but also no deterioration of behavioral problems in children with PWS during long-term GH treatment.
关于 Prader-Willi 综合征(PWS)患儿行为以及生长激素(GH)治疗效果的信息十分有限。有研究表明,GH 治疗过程中患儿的行为问题有所减少。本研究对 42 名 3.5-14 岁的 PWS 患儿进行了为期 2 年的随机对照 GH 治疗试验(RCT),并在 GH 治疗 8 年后进行了纵向研究。每年使用发育行为残疾儿童检查表(DBC)和荷兰儿童社会行为问卷(CSBQ)评估儿童的行为。与具有相似智力残疾的患儿相比,PWS 患儿的 DBC 行为问题评分相似。然而,“社会残疾”亚量表的评分明显高于 DBC 总分(p<0.01)。较低的智商与更多的自我关注行为、更多的沟通问题和更多的一般行为问题有关。与具有相似智力残疾的患儿相比,CSBQ 评估的行为问题相似,但 PWS 患儿在“不适应”、“理解”和“刻板”亚量表上的评分明显高于 CSBQ 总分(所有亚量表 p<0.05,“不适应”亚量表 p=0.001)。RCT 期间和 GH 治疗 8 年后均未观察到 GH 治疗的显著影响。PWS 患儿的行为问题与具有相似智力残疾的参考人群相似。社会问题是 PWS 中最明显的行为问题。与我们的预期和家长报告相反,我们的研究表明,在长期 GH 治疗过程中,PWS 患儿的行为问题没有改善,也没有恶化。