Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Chemical Engineering, Environmental Engineering Laboratory, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece; Centre for Research and Technology Hellas, Chemical Process and Energy Resources Institute, Natural and Renewable Resource Exploitation Laboratory, 57001 Thessaloniki, Greece.
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Chemical Engineering, Environmental Engineering Laboratory, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece; Centre for Research and Technology Hellas, Chemical Process and Energy Resources Institute, Natural and Renewable Resource Exploitation Laboratory, 57001 Thessaloniki, Greece.
Environ Res. 2015 Feb;137:147-56. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2014.12.009. Epub 2014 Dec 23.
This study deals with the assessment of the cancer risk attributable to PAH exposure, attributable to the increased use of biomass for space heating in Greece in the winter of 2012-2013. Three fractions of particulates (PM1, PM2.5 and PM10) were measured in two sampling sites (urban/residential and traffic-influenced) followed by chemical analysis of 19 PAHs and levoglucosan (used as a biomarker tracer). PAH-induced lung cancer risk was estimated by a comprehensive methodology that incorporated human respiratory tract deposition modelling in order to estimate the toxic equivalent concentration (TEQ) at each target tissue. This allowed us to further differentiate internal exposure and risk by age groups. Results showed that all PM fractions are higher in Greece during the cold months of the year, mainly due to biomass use for space heating. PAH and levoglucosan levels were highly correlated, indicating that particles emitted from biomass combustion are more toxic than PM emitted from other sources. The estimated lung cancer risk was non-negligible for residents close to the urban background monitoring site. Higher risk was estimated for infants and children, due to the higher bodyweight normalized dose and the human respiratory tract (HRT) physiology. HRT structure and physiology in youngsters favor deposition of particles that are smaller and more toxic per unit mass. In all cases, the estimated risk (5.7E-07 and 1.4E-06 for the urban background site and 1.4E-07 to 5.0E-07 for the traffic site) was lower to the one estimated by the conventional methodology (2.8E-06 and 9.7E-07 for the urban background and the traffic site respectively) that is based on Inhalation Unit Risk; the latter assumes that all PAHs adsorbed on particles are taken up by humans. With the methodology proposed herein, the estimated risk presents a 5-7 times difference between the two sampling sites (depending on the age group). These differences could not have been identified had we relied only on conventional risk assessment method. Consequently, the actual cancer risk attributable to PAHs on PM emitted from biomass burning would have been significantly underestimated.
本研究评估了 2012-2013 年冬季希腊因使用更多生物质进行空间供暖而导致的与 PAH 暴露相关的癌症风险。在两个采样点(城市/居民区和交通影响区)测量了三种颗粒物(PM1、PM2.5 和 PM10),随后对 19 种 PAHs 和左旋葡聚糖(用作生物标志物示踪剂)进行了化学分析。通过综合方法评估了 PAH 引起的肺癌风险,该方法纳入了人类呼吸道沉积建模,以估计每个靶组织的等效毒性浓度 (TEQ)。这使我们能够进一步根据年龄组区分内部暴露和风险。结果表明,在一年中寒冷的月份,希腊的所有 PM 分数都较高,主要是由于使用生物质进行空间供暖。PAH 和左旋葡聚糖水平高度相关,表明来自生物质燃烧的颗粒比来自其他来源的 PM 更具毒性。靠近城市背景监测点的居民的肺癌风险估计不容忽视。由于体重归一化剂量和人体呼吸道 (HRT) 生理学较高,估计婴儿和儿童的风险更高。年轻人的 HRT 结构和生理学有利于沉积更小、单位质量毒性更高的颗粒。在所有情况下,估计风险(城市背景点为 5.7E-07 和 1.4E-06,交通点为 1.4E-07 至 5.0E-07)均低于传统方法(城市背景和交通点分别为 2.8E-06 和 9.7E-07)所估计的风险,传统方法基于吸入单位风险;后者假设所有吸附在颗粒上的 PAHs 都被人类吸收。使用本文提出的方法,两个采样点之间的估计风险存在 5-7 倍的差异(取决于年龄组)。如果我们仅依赖于传统的风险评估方法,就无法识别这些差异。因此,归因于生物质燃烧产生的 PM 中 PAHs 的实际癌症风险将被大大低估。