Branger B, Rouger V, Berlie I, Beucher A, Flamant C, N'guyen The Tich S, Garcia J, Brossier J-P, Montcho Y, Hanf M, Roze J-C
« Sécurité naissance-naître ensemble » des Pays de la Loire, 2, rue de la Loire, 1, allée Baco, 44200 Nantes, France.
« Grandir ensemble », CHU, 44093 Nantes, France.
Arch Pediatr. 2015 Feb;22(2):171-80. doi: 10.1016/j.arcped.2014.10.027. Epub 2014 Dec 26.
Vulnerable children are at-risk newborns including premature infants and some children with pathologies presented by fear anomalies and deficiencies, most particularly neurological. Monitoring is based on the detection of these abnormalities and their early management. The organization of this monitoring system is based on a network of doctors, mostly pediatricians, trained regularly. The objective of this review was to assess the resources, means, and results of 10 years of follow-up.
The Pays de la Loire network includes 24 maternity wards and 13 neonatal departments. Annual admissions are around 5000 newborns to approximately 45,000 annual births. Upon discharge of newborns, born prematurely at 34 weeks of gestation (WG) or less, or term infants with neurological problems, parents are asked to have their child monitored by a referring doctor. During the consultation, a reference document is filled out by the doctor and sent to the project manager for data collection and specific compensation for private practitioners. Standardized questionnaires were used such as the ASQ (Ages and Stage Questionnaire) completed by parents, the developmental quotient (DQ) with the Lézine Brunet-Revised test (BLR), the intelligence quotient (IQ) with the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (WIPPSI III) completed by psychologists employed in the network, and a questionnaire completed by the teacher at 5 years of age.
The network started on 1st March 2003, and 28th February 2013, after 10 years of inclusion, 10,800 children had been included. This population accounts for 2.4% of all annual births: 1.1% were included for prematurity less than 33 weeks and 0.25% were term-born infants. The characteristics of children are presented with gestational age, birth weight, and obstetric and neonatal pathologies. The percentage of these children followed was 80% at 2 years and 63% at 5 years. At 2 years, the results are presented according to gestational age with approximately 60% of children without disabilities at 25-26 WG, 73% at 27-28 WG, 77% at 29-30 WG, and 86% at 31-32 WG. Absorptions are diverse and vary according to the age of the child with physical therapy, psychomotor skill work, speech therapy, hearing and vision consultations, and psychology/psychiatry. Assessment tools were refined by specific analyses: the ASQ 24 months (completed by parents) was deemed valid and predictive with respect to IQ (abandoned in 2012), and the grid completed by the teacher was found to predict abnormalities in 5 years.
The Pays de la Loire monitoring network has met its initial objective, namely to detect disabilities early and provide practical help to parents in a population of vulnerable children. Benefits for professionals and other children not followed in the network were observed, with an increase in pediatricians' skills. The benefits of the evaluation results are more difficult to assess with the care than neonatal care in obstetrics. The sustainability of such a network seems assured for healthcare professionals, provided that funding is maintained by the health authorities.
脆弱儿童是指高危新生儿,包括早产儿以及一些存在恐惧异常和缺陷(尤其是神经方面)的患病儿童。监测基于对这些异常情况的检测及其早期管理。该监测系统的组织架构基于一个由医生组成的网络,其中大多数是儿科医生,他们会定期接受培训。本综述的目的是评估10年随访的资源、手段和结果。
卢瓦尔河地区网络包括24个产科病房和13个新生儿科室。每年入院的新生儿约5000例,年出生人口约45000例。对于妊娠34周及以下早产出生的新生儿或有神经问题的足月儿,在其出院时,会要求家长让孩子由转诊医生进行监测。在会诊期间,医生会填写一份参考文件并发送给项目经理,用于数据收集以及对私人执业医生的特定补偿。使用了标准化问卷,如家长填写的《年龄与阶段问卷》(ASQ)、通过勒津-布鲁内修订测试(BLR)得出的发育商(DQ)、由该网络雇佣的心理学家使用韦氏学前和小学智力量表(WIPPSI III)得出的智商(IQ),以及由教师在孩子5岁时填写的问卷。
该网络于2003年3月1日启动,到2013年2月28日,经过10年的纳入,共纳入了10800名儿童。这一群体占每年所有出生人口的2.4%:孕周小于33周的早产儿童占1.1%,足月儿占0.25%。呈现了儿童的孕周、出生体重以及产科和新生儿疾病等特征。这些儿童的随访率在2岁时为80%,在5岁时为63%。在2岁时,根据孕周呈现结果,在25 - 26孕周时约60%的儿童无残疾,27 - 28孕周时为73%,29 - 30孕周时为77%,31 - 32孕周时为86%。治疗方式多样,会根据孩子的年龄进行物理治疗、运动技能训练、言语治疗、听力和视力会诊以及心理/精神科治疗。通过特定分析对评估工具进行了完善:24个月的ASQ(由家长填写)被认为对于智商(2012年停用)有效且具有预测性,教师填写的表格被发现能够预测5岁时的异常情况。
卢瓦尔河地区监测网络实现了其最初目标,即在脆弱儿童群体中早期发现残疾并为家长提供实际帮助。观察到对专业人员以及网络中未接受随访的其他儿童有益,儿科医生的技能有所提高。与产科的新生儿护理相比,评估结果在护理方面的益处更难评估。只要卫生当局维持资金支持,这样一个网络对医疗保健专业人员来说其可持续性似乎是有保障的。