Tully Jeffrey, Dameff Christian, Kaib Susan, Moffitt Maricela
Dr. Tully is a first-year resident training in pediatrics, Phoenix Children's Hospital, Phoenix, Arizona. Dr. Dameff is a first-year resident training in emergency medicine, Maricopa Medical Center, Phoenix, Arizona. Dr. Kaib is assistant director, Doctoring Curriculum, Department of Academic Affairs, University of Arizona, College of Medicine: Phoenix, Phoenix, Arizona. Dr. Moffitt is director, Doctoring Curriculum, Department of Academic Affairs, University of Arizona, College of Medicine: Phoenix, Phoenix, Arizona.
Acad Med. 2015 Mar;90(3):314-6. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000000620.
Medical education today frequently includes standardized patient (SP) encounters to teach history-taking, physical exam, and communication skills. However, traditional wall-mounted cameras, used to record video for faculty and student feedback and evaluation, provide a limited view of key nonverbal communication behaviors during clinical encounters.
In 2013, 30 second-year medical students participated in an end-of-life module that included SP encounters in which the SPs used Google Glass to record their first-person perspective. Students reviewed the Google Glass video and traditional videos and then completed a postencounter, self-evaluation survey and a follow-up survey about the experience.
Google Glass was used successfully to record 30 student/SP encounters. One temporary Google Glass hardware failure was observed. Of the 30 students, 7 (23%) reported a "positive, nondistracting experience"; 11 (37%) a "positive, initially distracting experience"; 5 (17%) a "neutral experience"; and 3 (10%) a "negative experience." Four students (13%) opted to withhold judgment until they reviewed the videos but reported Google Glass as "distracting." According to follow-up survey responses, 16 students (of 23; 70%) found Google Glass "worth including in the [clinical skills program]," whereas 7 (30%) did not.
Google Glass can be used to video record students during SP encounters and provides a novel perspective for the analysis and evaluation of their interpersonal communication skills and nonverbal behaviors. Next steps include a larger, more rigorous comparison of Google Glass versus traditional videos and expanded use of this technology in other aspects of the clinical skills training program.
如今的医学教育常常包含标准化病人(SP)问诊环节,以教授病史采集、体格检查和沟通技巧。然而,用于录制视频以供教师和学生反馈及评估的传统壁挂式摄像头,在临床问诊过程中对关键非语言沟通行为的视野有限。
2013年,30名二年级医学生参加了一个临终关怀模块,其中包括标准化病人问诊环节,标准化病人使用谷歌眼镜记录第一人称视角。学生们观看了谷歌眼镜录制的视频和传统视频,然后完成了问诊后的自我评估调查以及关于此次体验的后续调查。
谷歌眼镜成功用于录制30次学生/标准化病人问诊。观察到一次谷歌眼镜硬件临时故障。在30名学生中,7名(23%)报告有“积极、无干扰的体验”;11名(37%)有“积极、起初有干扰的体验”;5名(17%)有“中立体验”;3名(10%)有“消极体验”。4名学生(13%)选择在观看视频之前暂不做判断,但报告称谷歌眼镜“有干扰”。根据后续调查回复,23名学生中的16名(70%)认为谷歌眼镜“值得纳入[临床技能项目]”,而7名(30%)则不这么认为。
谷歌眼镜可用于在标准化病人问诊期间对学生进行视频录制,并为分析和评估他们的人际沟通技巧及非语言行为提供新视角。下一步包括对谷歌眼镜和传统视频进行更大规模、更严格的比较,并在临床技能培训项目的其他方面扩大该技术的应用。