McDonald Kristina L, Benish-Weisman Maya, O'Brien Christopher T, Ungvary Stephen
Department of Psychology, University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL, 35487, USA.
Department of Counseling and Human Development, University of Haifa, 3498838, Mount Carmel, Haifa, Israel.
J Youth Adolesc. 2015 Dec;44(12):2245-56. doi: 10.1007/s10964-014-0246-0. Epub 2015 Jan 6.
Recent research has identified youth who utilize both aggressive and prosocial behavior with peers. Although the social values and motivations associated with aggression and prosocial behavior have been well studied, the values of youth who utilize both aggression and prosocial behavior are unknown. The current study identified groups of adolescents based on peer nominations of aggression and prosocial behavior from both Israel (n = 569; 56.94% Arab, 43.06% Jewish; 53.78% female) and the United States (n = 342; 67.54% African-American; 32.46% European-American; 50.88% female). Self-enhancement, self-transcendence, openness-to-change, and conservation values predicted behavioral group membership. Power values predicted membership in the aggressive group relative to the aggressive-prosocial, prosocial, and low-both groups. For Israeli boys, openness-to-change values predicted membership in the aggressive-prosocial group relative to the prosocial group. The values of aggressive-prosocial youth were more similar to the values of prosocial peers than to aggressive peers, suggesting that motivational interventions for aggressive-prosocial youth should differ in important ways than those for aggressive youth.
最近的研究发现,有些青少年在与同龄人交往时既会表现出攻击性行为,也会表现出亲社会行为。虽然与攻击性行为和亲社会行为相关的社会价值观和动机已经得到了充分研究,但那些既表现出攻击性行为又表现出亲社会行为的青少年的价值观却尚不明确。当前的研究根据来自以色列(n = 569;56.94%为阿拉伯人,43.06%为犹太人;53.78%为女性)和美国(n = 342;67.54%为非裔美国人;32.46%为欧裔美国人;50.88%为女性)的同龄人对攻击性行为和亲社会行为的提名,确定了青少年群体。自我提升、自我超越、对变化的开放性和保守价值观预测了行为群体成员身份。相对于攻击亲社会型、亲社会型和低双型群体,权力价值观预测了攻击型群体的成员身份。对于以色列男孩来说,相对于亲社会型群体,对变化的开放性价值观预测了攻击亲社会型群体的成员身份。攻击亲社会型青少年的价值观与亲社会同龄人更相似,而不是与攻击型同龄人相似,这表明针对攻击亲社会型青少年的动机干预在重要方面应与针对攻击型青少年的干预有所不同。