Michelson Edward A, Hanley Daniel, Chabot Robert, Prichep Leslie S
Department Emergency Medicine, University Hospitals Case Medical Center, Cleveland, OH.
Acad Emerg Med. 2015 Jan;22(1):67-72. doi: 10.1111/acem.12561.
Acute stroke is a leading cause of brain injury and death and requires rapid and accurate diagnosis. Noncontrast head computed tomography (CT) is the first line for diagnosis in the emergency department (ED). Complicating rapid triage are presenting conditions that clinically mimic stroke. There is an extensive literature reporting clinical utility of brain electrical activity in early diagnosis and management of acute stroke. However, existing technologies do not lend themselves to easily acquired rapid evaluation. This investigation used an independently derived classifier algorithm for the identification of traumatic structural brain injury based on brain electrical activity recorded from a reduced frontal montage to explore the potential clinical utility of such an approach in acute stroke assessment.
Adult patients (age 18 to 95 years) presenting with stroke-like and/or altered mental status symptoms were recruited from urban academic EDs as part of a large research study evaluating the clinical utility of quantitative brain electrical activity in acutely brain-injured patients. All patients from the parent study who had confirmed strokes, and a control group of stroke mimics (those with final ED diagnoses of migraine or syncope), were selected for this study. All stroke patients underwent head CT scans. Some patients with negative CTs had further imaging with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Ten minutes of electroencephalographic data were acquired on a hand-held device in development, from five frontal electrodes. Data analyses were done offline. A Structural Brain Injury Index (SBII) was derived using an independently developed binary discriminant classification algorithm whose input was specified features of brain electrical activity. The SBII was previously found to have high accuracy in the identification of traumatic brain-injured patients who were found to have brain injury on CT (CT+). This algorithm was applied to patients in this study and used to classify patients as CT+ or not CT+. Performance was assessed using sensitivity, specificity, and negative and positive predictive values (NPV, PPV).
Forty-eight stroke patients (31 ischemic and 17 hemorrhagic) and 135 stroke mimic controls were included. Within the ischemic population, approximately half were CT- but later confirmed for stroke with MRI (CT-/MRI+). Sensitivity to stroke was 91.7%, specificity 50.4% (to stroke mimic), NPV 94.4%, and PPV 39.6%. Eighty percent of the CT-/MRI+ ischemic strokes were correctly identified at the time of the CT- scan.
Despite a small population and the use of a classifier without the benefit of training on a stroke population, these data suggest that a rapidly acquired, easy-to-use system to assess brain electrical activity at the time of evaluation of acute stroke could be a valuable adjunct to current clinical practice.
急性中风是脑损伤和死亡的主要原因,需要快速准确的诊断。非增强头部计算机断层扫描(CT)是急诊科(ED)诊断的一线方法。使快速分诊复杂化的是临床上模仿中风的表现情况。有大量文献报道脑电活动在急性中风早期诊断和管理中的临床效用。然而,现有技术并不便于轻松获得快速评估。本研究使用一种基于从简化额叶导联记录的脑电活动独立推导的分类器算法来识别创伤性结构性脑损伤,以探索这种方法在急性中风评估中的潜在临床效用。
从城市学术急诊科招募出现类似中风和/或精神状态改变症状的成年患者(年龄18至95岁),作为一项评估急性脑损伤患者定量脑电活动临床效用的大型研究的一部分。从母研究中所有确诊中风的患者以及一组中风模仿者对照组(最终ED诊断为偏头痛或晕厥的患者)中选取本研究对象。所有中风患者均接受头部CT扫描。一些CT检查结果为阴性的患者进一步进行了磁共振成像(MRI)检查。使用一种正在研发的手持设备从五个额叶电极采集十分钟的脑电图数据。数据分析在离线状态下进行。使用一种独立开发的二元判别分类算法得出结构性脑损伤指数(SBII),该算法的输入是脑电活动的特定特征。先前发现SBII在识别CT检查发现有脑损伤的创伤性脑损伤患者(CT+)方面具有很高的准确性。该算法应用于本研究中的患者,并用于将患者分类为CT+或非CT+。使用敏感性、特异性以及阴性和阳性预测值(NPV、PPV)评估性能。
纳入了48例中风患者(31例缺血性中风和17例出血性中风)和135例中风模仿者对照组。在缺血性中风患者群体中,约一半患者CT检查结果为阴性,但后来通过MRI确诊为中风(CT-/MRI+)。对中风的敏感性为91.7%,特异性为50.4%(针对中风模仿者),NPV为94.4%,PPV为39.6%。80%的CT-/MRI+缺血性中风在CT扫描时被正确识别。
尽管样本量较小且使用的分类器未从中风患者群体中受益进行训练,但这些数据表明,在急性中风评估时快速获取、易于使用的脑电活动评估系统可能是当前临床实践中有价值的辅助手段。