Li Tiantian, Yan Meilin, Ma Wenjun, Ban Jie, Liu Tao, Lin Hualiang, Liu Zhaorong
Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Institute for Environmental Health and Related Product Safety, No. 29 Nanwei Road, Xicheng District, Beijing, 100050, China,
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2015 Jun;22(11):8738-46. doi: 10.1007/s11356-014-4055-5. Epub 2015 Jan 10.
Epidemiological studies have widely demonstrated association between ambient ozone and mortality, though controversy remains, and most of them only use a certain metric to assess ozone levels. However, in China, few studies have investigated the acute effects of ambient ozone, and rare studies have compared health effects of multiple daily metrics of ozone. The present analysis aimed to explore variability of estimated health effects by using multiple temporal ozone metrics. Six metrics of ozone, 1-h maximum, maximum 8-h average, 24-h average, daytime average, nighttime average, and commute average, were used in a time-series study to investigate acute mortality associated with ambient ozone pollution in Guangzhou, China, using 3 years of daily data (2006-2008). We used generalized linear models with Poisson regression incorporating natural spline functions to analyze the mortality, ozone, and covariate data. We also examined the association by season. Daily 1- and 8-h maximum, 24-h average, and daytime average concentrations yielded statistically significant associations with mortality. An interquartile range (IQR) of O3 metric increase of each ozone metric (lag 2) corresponds to 2.92 % (95 % confidence interval (CI) 0.24 to 5.66), 3.60 % (95 % CI, 0.92 to 8.49), 3.03 % (95 % CI, 0.57 to 15.8), and 3.31 % (95 % CI, 0.69 to 10.4) increase in daily non-accidental mortality, respectively. Nighttime and commute metrics were weakly associated with increased mortality rate. The associations between ozone and mortality appeared to be more evident during cool season than in the warm season. Results were robust to adjustment for co-pollutants, weather, and time trend. In conclusion, these results indicated that ozone, as a widespread pollutant, adversely affects mortality in Guangzhou.
流行病学研究广泛证明了环境臭氧与死亡率之间的关联,尽管仍存在争议,并且其中大多数研究仅使用某种指标来评估臭氧水平。然而,在中国,很少有研究调查环境臭氧的急性影响,而且极少有研究比较臭氧的多种每日指标对健康的影响。本分析旨在通过使用多个时间臭氧指标来探索估计的健康影响的变异性。在一项时间序列研究中,使用了臭氧的六个指标,即1小时最大值、最大8小时平均值、24小时平均值、白天平均值、夜间平均值和通勤平均值,利用中国广州3年(2006 - 2008年)的每日数据来调查与环境臭氧污染相关的急性死亡率。我们使用了带有泊松回归并纳入自然样条函数的广义线性模型来分析死亡率、臭氧和协变量数据。我们还按季节检查了这种关联。每日1小时和8小时最大值、24小时平均值以及白天平均值浓度与死亡率呈现出具有统计学意义的关联。每个臭氧指标(滞后2)的臭氧指标增加一个四分位数间距(IQR)分别对应每日非意外死亡率增加2.92%(95%置信区间(CI)0.24至5.66)、3.60%(95% CI,0.92至8.49)、3.03%(95% CI,0.57至15.8)和3.31%(95% CI,0.69至10.4)。夜间和通勤指标与死亡率增加的关联较弱。臭氧与死亡率之间的关联在凉爽季节似乎比温暖季节更明显。对共污染物、天气和时间趋势进行调整后,结果依然稳健。总之,这些结果表明,臭氧作为一种广泛存在的污染物,对广州的死亡率有不利影响。