Droby Amgad, Lukas Carsten, Schänzer Anne, Spiwoks-Becker Isabella, Giorgio Antonio, Gold Ralf, De Stefano Nicola, Kugel Harald, Deppe Michael, Wiendl Heinz, Meuth Sven G, Acker Till, Zipp Frauke, Deichmann Ralf
Department of Neurology, University Medical Center of the Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Germany; Neuroimaging Center (NIC) of the Focus Program Translational Neuroscience (FTN), Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany.
Department of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, St. Josef Hospital, Ruhr-University Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
Neuroimage. 2015 Apr 15;110:11-21. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2015.01.028. Epub 2015 Jan 14.
Multi-centre MRI studies of the brain are essential for enrolling large and diverse patient cohorts, as required for the investigation of heterogeneous neurological and psychiatric diseases. However, the multi-site comparison of standard MRI data sets that are weighted with respect to tissue parameters such as the relaxation times (T1, T2) and proton density (PD) may be problematic, as signal intensities and image contrasts depend on site-specific details such as the sequences used, imaging parameters, and sensitivity profiles of the radiofrequency (RF) coils. Water or gel phantoms are frequently used for long-term and/or inter-site quality assessment. However, these phantoms hardly mimic the structure, shape, size or tissue distribution of the human brain. The goals of this study were: (1) to validate the long-term stability of a human post-mortem brain phantom, performing quantitative mapping of T1, T2, and PD, and the magnetization transfer ratio (MTR) over a period of 18months; (2) to acquire and analyse data for this phantom and the brain of a healthy control (HC) in a multi-centre study for MRI protocol standardization in four centres, while conducting a voxel-wise as well as whole brain grey (GM) and white matter (WM) tissue volume comparison. MTR, T2, and the quotient of PD in WM and GM were stable in the post-mortem brain with no significant changes. T1 was found to decrease from 267/236ms (GM/WM) to 234/216ms between 5 and 17weeks post embedment, stabilizing during an 18-month period following the first scan at about 215/190ms. The volumetric measures, based on T1-weighted MP-RAGE images obtained at all participating centres, revealed inter- and intra-centre variations in the evaluated GM and WM volumes that displayed similar trends in both the post-mortem brain as well as the HC. At a confidence level of 95%, brain regions such as the brainstem, deep GM structures as well as boundaries between GM and WM tissues were found to be less reproducible than other brain regions in all participating centres. The results demonstrate that a post-mortem brain phantom may be used as a reliable tool for multi-centre MR studies.
对于招募大量且多样的患者队列而言,脑部多中心MRI研究至关重要,这是研究异质性神经和精神疾病所必需的。然而,对基于诸如弛豫时间(T1、T2)和质子密度(PD)等组织参数加权的标准MRI数据集进行多站点比较可能存在问题,因为信号强度和图像对比度取决于特定站点的细节,如所使用的序列、成像参数以及射频(RF)线圈的灵敏度分布。水或凝胶体模经常用于长期和/或站点间的质量评估。然而,这些体模很难模拟人脑的结构、形状、大小或组织分布。本研究的目标是:(1)验证人类尸检脑体模的长期稳定性,在18个月的时间内对T1、T2、PD以及磁化传递率(MTR)进行定量映射;(2)在一项多中心研究中,为该体模和一名健康对照(HC)的大脑采集并分析数据,以实现四个中心的MRI协议标准化,同时进行体素级以及全脑灰质(GM)和白质(WM)组织体积比较。在尸检脑中,MTR、T2以及WM和GM中PD的商是稳定的,没有显著变化。发现T1在包埋后5至17周之间从267/236毫秒(GM/WM)降至234/216毫秒,在首次扫描后的18个月期间稳定在约215/190毫秒。基于所有参与中心获得的T1加权MP-RAGE图像的体积测量显示,在评估的GM和WM体积中存在中心间和中心内差异,在尸检脑和HC中均呈现相似趋势。在95%的置信水平下,发现在所有参与中心,脑干、深部GM结构以及GM和WM组织之间的边界等脑区的可重复性低于其他脑区。结果表明,尸检脑体模可作为多中心MR研究的可靠工具。