Xu Junfang, Wang Jian, Liu Ruiyun, Xing Jinshui, Su Lei, Yu Fenghua, Lu Mingshan
Center for Health Economic Experiments and Public Policy, School of Public Health, Shandong University, China,
J Ment Health Policy Econ. 2014 Dec;17(4):173-82.
Mental health is increasingly becoming a huge public health issue in China. Yet for various cultural, healthcare system, and social economic reasons, people with mental health need have long been under-served in China. In order to inform the current on-going health care reform, empirical evidences on the economic burden of mental illnesses in China are urgently needed to contribute to health policy makers' understanding of the potential benefits to society from allocating more resources to preventing and treating mental illness. However, the cost of mental illnesses and particularly its trend in China remains largely unknown.
To investigate the trend of health care resource utilization among inpatients with mental illnesses in China, and to analyze what are the factors influencing the inpatient costs.
Our study sample included 15,721 patients, both adults and children, who were hospitalized over an eight-year period (2005-2012) in Shandong Center for Mental Health (SCMH), the only provincial psychiatric hospital in Shandong province, China. Data were extracted from the Health Information System (HIS) at SCMH, with detailed and itemized cost data on all inpatient expenses incurred during hospitalization. The identification of the patients was based on the ICD-10 diagnoses recorded in the HIS. Descriptive analysis was done to analyze the trend of hospitalization cost and length of stay during the study period. Multivariate stepwise regression analysis was conducted to assess the factors that influence hospitalization cost.
Among the inpatients in our sample, the most common mental disorders were schizophrenia, schizotypal and delusional disorders. The disease which had the highest per capita hospital expense was behavioral and emotional disorders with onset usually occurring in childhood and adolescence (RMB 8,828.4; US$ 1,419.4, as compared to the average reported household annual income of US$ 2,095.3 in China). The average annual growth rate of per capita hospitalization cost was 23.6%, with the inpatient cost reaching RMB 11,949 (US$ 1921.1) in 2012. The hospitalization cost was found to be strongly associated with hospital length of stay, level of care, age, employment status, admission diagnoses, and frequency of hospitalization.
Our study found that mental health inpatient resources use, particularly hospitalization cost, has been growing at an increasing rate. In our sample, hospitalization cost nearly tripled from 2005 to 2012. Mental illnesses and the related economic burden on the population will continue to grow, making mental health a major public health issue in China. Hospital length of stay was found to be increasing in our sample, and positively correlated with hospitalization cost. Childhood and adolescence behavioral and emotional disorders were found to be significantly associated with higher inpatient cost.
The policy implications generated from the results of this study are two-fold: first of all, in order to meet the growing need of mental health care in China, the government needs to significantly increase its spending in preventing and treating mental illnesses. Second, cost containment in inpatient care would become a major challenge for mental health policy makers in China. Government support, clinical practices and guideline development, as well as research are urgently needed to promote mental health prevention and improve the efficiency of mental health system in China. The current mental health system, like the overall healthcare system in China, relies heavily on hospital inpatient care. In order to build a sustainable mental health care system to meet increasing population need in China, it is crucial to integrate mental health care reform with the ongoing primary health care reform. Future mental health policy reform and research in China should put more focus on how to strengthen primary care system as well as community support, establish effective two-tier referring mechanism between hospital and primary care system, and to ensure continuity of care.
在中国,心理健康正日益成为一个重大的公共卫生问题。然而,由于各种文化、医疗体系和社会经济原因,中国心理健康需求者长期以来一直未得到充分服务。为了为当前正在进行的医疗改革提供参考,迫切需要关于中国精神疾病经济负担的实证证据,以帮助卫生政策制定者了解为预防和治疗精神疾病分配更多资源可能给社会带来的潜在益处。然而,中国精神疾病的成本,尤其是其趋势在很大程度上仍不为人所知。
调查中国精神疾病住院患者医疗资源利用的趋势,并分析影响住院费用的因素。
我们的研究样本包括15721名患者,有成人也有儿童,他们在八年期间(2005 - 2012年)在中国山东省唯一的省级精神病医院——山东省精神卫生中心住院。数据从山东省精神卫生中心的健康信息系统(HIS)中提取,包含住院期间所有住院费用的详细和分项成本数据。患者的识别基于HIS中记录的国际疾病分类第十版(ICD - 10)诊断。进行描述性分析以分析研究期间住院费用和住院时间的趋势。进行多元逐步回归分析以评估影响住院费用的因素。
在我们样本中的住院患者中,最常见的精神障碍是精神分裂症、分裂型和妄想性障碍。人均住院费用最高的疾病是通常在儿童和青少年期发病的行为和情绪障碍(8828.4元人民币;1419.4美元,相比中国报告的家庭年均收入2095.3美元)。人均住院费用的年均增长率为23.6%,2012年住院费用达到11949元人民币(1921.1美元)。发现住院费用与住院时间、护理级别、年龄、就业状况、入院诊断和住院频率密切相关。
我们的研究发现,精神卫生住院资源利用,尤其是住院费用,一直在以越来越快的速度增长。在我们的样本中,住院费用从2005年到2012年几乎增长了两倍。精神疾病及其给人群带来的相关经济负担将继续增加,使心理健康成为中国的一个重大公共卫生问题。在我们的样本中发现住院时间在增加,且与住院费用呈正相关。发现儿童和青少年期行为和情绪障碍与较高的住院费用显著相关。
本研究结果产生的政策启示有两方面:首先,为了满足中国日益增长的心理健康护理需求,政府需要大幅增加在预防和治疗精神疾病方面的支出。其次,控制住院护理成本将成为中国心理健康政策制定者面临的一项重大挑战。迫切需要政府支持、临床实践与指南制定以及研究,以促进中国的心理健康预防并提高心理健康系统的效率。当前的心理健康系统,如同中国整体医疗系统一样,严重依赖医院住院护理。为了建立一个可持续的心理健康护理系统以满足中国不断增长的人口需求,将心理健康护理改革与正在进行的初级卫生保健改革相结合至关重要。中国未来的心理健康政策改革和研究应更多地关注如何加强初级保健系统以及社区支持,建立医院与初级保健系统之间有效的两级转诊机制,并确保护理的连续性。