Arnold Michael A, Nicol Kathleen K
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Nationwide Children's Hospital, and Department of Pathology, The Ohio State University College of Medicine, Columbus, OH, USA.
Pediatr Dev Pathol. 2015 Mar-Apr;18(2):139-45. doi: 10.2350/14-08-1542-OA.1. Epub 2015 Jan 27.
The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) offers standardized and widely understood diagnostic categories for reporting thyroid cytology diagnoses. We compared the utility of TBSRTC categories in pediatric cytology diagnoses and pediatric intraoperative frozen section diagnoses. We examined the experience of our primary and referral care center over a 20-year period. This included 182 thyroidectomy patients who underwent 64 preoperative fine-needle aspirations and 91 intraoperative frozen section evaluations, including 38 patients evaluated sequentially by each method. All diagnoses were retrospectively reclassified into TBSRTC categories and correlated with the final thyroidectomy diagnoses. For each sampling method, malignant final diagnoses were observed at similar frequencies to rates predicted by TBSRTC. Malignant final diagnoses following fine-needle aspiration or frozen section diagnoses in TBSRTC categories other than malignant or suspicious for malignancy most often resulted from difficulty in detecting papillary carcinoma, including difficulty detecting the nuclear characteristics of papillary carcinoma in frozen sections. The limitations of needle biopsy and frozen section evaluations differ, yet serial utilization of these procedures was rarely informative. Based on the experience of our institution, classification of cytology and frozen section diagnosis by TBSRTC predicts a risk of malignancy similar to the guidance offered by TBSRTC. We recommend including a TBSRTC category when reporting either thyroid cytology or frozen section diagnoses in children.
《甲状腺细胞病理学报告的贝塞斯达系统》(TBSRTC)为报告甲状腺细胞诊断提供了标准化且被广泛理解的诊断类别。我们比较了TBSRTC类别在儿科细胞诊断和儿科术中冰冻切片诊断中的效用。我们研究了我们的一级和转诊护理中心在20年期间的经验。这包括182例接受甲状腺切除术的患者,他们接受了64次术前细针穿刺和91次术中冰冻切片评估,其中38例患者通过每种方法进行了序贯评估。所有诊断均回顾性重新分类为TBSRTC类别,并与最终甲状腺切除诊断相关。对于每种采样方法,观察到的恶性最终诊断频率与TBSRTC预测的发生率相似。在TBSRTC类别中,除恶性或疑似恶性外,细针穿刺或冰冻切片诊断后的恶性最终诊断最常是由于难以检测到乳头状癌,包括在冰冻切片中难以检测到乳头状癌的核特征。针吸活检和冰冻切片评估的局限性不同,但这些程序的连续使用很少能提供有用信息。基于我们机构的经验,通过TBSRTC对细胞学和冰冻切片诊断进行分类预测的恶性风险与TBSRTC提供的指导相似。我们建议在报告儿童甲状腺细胞学或冰冻切片诊断时包括TBSRTC类别。