Meluzinová P, Kopp L, Edelmann K, Obruba P, Avenarius J
Klinika úrazové chirurgie, Masarykova nemocnice v Ústí nad Labem, o. z., Krajská zdravotní, a. s.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2014;81(6):399-406.
The aim was to determine indication criteria for use of arthroscopy in the treatment of post-traumatic changes in the elbow joint, to present the surgical technique and to evaluate the results of a prospective study involving early follow-up of functional and radiographic outcomes of this treatment.
Between February 2010 and February 2013, arthroscopic surgery was carried out on 14 elbows in 14 patients at the Clinic of traumatology of Masaryk hospital in Ústí nad Labem. The group comprised seven men and seven women, with an average age of 40 years (range, 20 to 67 years). The indications for elbow arthroscopy included conditions after intraarticular fractures in fie, elbow dislocation in one, severe elbow contusion in four and complex injury to the elbow joint in four patients. Arthroscopic surgery was performed at an average of 11 months after the primary injury. The prospective follow-up lasted for an average of 12 months (range, 6 to 25). The outcomes of surgery were evaluated on the basis of radiograms and multiplanar reconstructions of CT images, elbow function was assessed using two rating systems, i.e., the Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS) and Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) score.
The average active range of motion (ROM) at the elbow joint was 118°/33° (145°-90°/60°-5°) before surgery and improved to 131°/5° (150°-90°/15°-0°), i.e., by 13°/28° (150°-90°/60°-0°) intra-operatively. The average fial value of elbow ROM after functional stabilization was 126°/16° (145°-90°/70°-0°), which means improvement by 8°/17° (45°-0°/50°-0°) or a total of 25°. On post-operative radiograms, the fidings were stable in 11 (79%) patients; elbows in three patients (21%) showed progression of degenerative changes (osteophyte formation and periarticular ossifiation). The fial functional scores, as assessed using the MEPS and HSS score systems, were 88.93 (55-100) and 88.29 (50-100) points (average/ range), respectively.
The study showed, in agreement with other authors' reports, that the degree of improvement in active range of motion and functional performance of the elbow is directly related to the severity of post-traumatic conditions. A certain residual ROM restriction usually remains. The outcome was poorer in patients with complex injuries of the elbow or in those with displaced intra-articular fractures of the joint and was also related to the severity of joint injury. Patients who were treated after a longer injury-to-surgery period and who suffered a more serious joint injury had more advanced arthritis, higher degree of joint contracture, worse pre-operative functional scores and less improvement in post-operative ROM of the elbow joint.
From the results of early functional assessments and radiographic fidings it can be concluded that the elbow joint arthroscopy is a safe and reliable technique to treat post-traumatic conditions caused by intrinsic factors in mild and moderate elbow stiffness. However, this method cannot be recommended in severe stiffness of the elbow or in stiffness due to extrinsic causes. Although the improvement in ROM achieved during the surgical procedure cannot be maintained in its full extent, this technique relieves persisting pain and signifiantly improves ROM of the elbow joint.
本研究旨在确定肘关节创伤后改变行关节镜治疗的适应证标准,介绍手术技术,并评估一项前瞻性研究的结果,该研究对该治疗的功能和影像学结果进行早期随访。
2010年2月至2013年2月期间,在拉贝河畔乌斯季的马萨里克医院创伤科,对14例患者的14个肘关节进行了关节镜手术。该组包括7名男性和7名女性,平均年龄40岁(范围20至67岁)。肘关节镜检查的适应证包括5例关节内骨折后情况、1例肘关节脱位、4例严重肘关节挫伤和4例肘关节复杂损伤。关节镜手术平均在初次损伤后11个月进行。前瞻性随访平均持续12个月(范围6至25个月)。根据X线片和CT图像的多平面重建评估手术结果,使用两种评分系统评估肘关节功能,即梅奥肘关节功能评分(MEPS)和特种外科医院(HSS)评分。
术前肘关节平均主动活动范围(ROM)为118°/33°(145°-90°/60°-5°),术中改善至131°/5°(150°-90°/15°-0°),即术中改善13°/28°(150°-90°/60°-0°)。功能稳定后肘关节ROM的平均最终值为126°/16°(145°-90°/70°-0°),这意味着改善了8°/17°(45°-0°/50°-0°),总共改善了25°。术后X线片显示,11例(79%)患者情况稳定;3例(21%)患者的肘关节出现退行性改变进展(骨赘形成和关节周围骨化)。使用MEPS和HSS评分系统评估的最终功能评分分别为88.93(55-100)分和88.29(50-100)分(平均/范围)。
本研究与其他作者的报告一致,表明肘关节主动活动范围和功能表现的改善程度与创伤后情况的严重程度直接相关。通常会残留一定程度的ROM受限。肘关节复杂损伤患者或关节内骨折移位患者的结果较差,这也与关节损伤的严重程度有关。受伤至手术间隔时间较长且关节损伤较严重的患者,关节炎更严重,关节挛缩程度更高,术前功能评分更差,术后肘关节ROM改善更少。
从早期功能评估和影像学检查结果可以得出结论,肘关节镜检查是治疗轻度和中度肘关节僵硬内在因素所致创伤后情况的一种安全可靠的技术。然而,对于严重肘关节僵硬或外在原因导致的僵硬,不推荐使用该方法。虽然手术过程中实现的ROM改善不能完全维持,但该技术可缓解持续疼痛并显著改善肘关节ROM。