Seiter J, Derungs A, Schuster-Amft C, Amft O, Tröster G
Julia Seiter, ETH Zurich, Gloriastrasse 35, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland, E-mail:
Methods Inf Med. 2015;54(3):248-55. doi: 10.3414/ME14-01-0082. Epub 2015 Feb 6.
Monitoring natural behavior and activity routines of hemiparetic rehabilitation patients across the day can provide valuable progress information for therapists and patients and contribute to an optimized rehabilitation process. In particular, continuous patient monitoring could add type, frequency and duration of daily life activity routines and hence complement standard clinical scores that are assessed for particular tasks only. Machine learning methods have been applied to infer activity routines from sensor data. However, supervised methods require activity annotations to build recognition models and thus require extensive patient supervision. Discovery methods, including topic models could provide patient routine information and deal with variability in activity and movement performance across patients. Topic models have been used to discover characteristic activity routine patterns of healthy individuals using activity primitives recognized from supervised sensor data. Yet, the applicability of topic models for hemiparetic rehabilitation patients and techniques to derive activity primitives without supervision needs to be addressed.
We investigate, 1) whether a topic model-based activity routine discovery framework can infer activity routines of rehabilitation patients from wearable motion sensor data. 2) We compare the performance of our topic model-based activity routine discovery using rule-based and clustering-based activity vocabulary.
We analyze the activity routine discovery in a dataset recorded with 11 hemiparetic rehabilitation patients during up to ten full recording days per individual in an ambulatory daycare rehabilitation center using wearable motion sensors attached to both wrists and the non-affected thigh. We introduce and compare rule-based and clustering-based activity vocabulary to process statistical and frequency acceleration features to activity words. Activity words were used for activity routine pattern discovery using topic models based on Latent Dirichlet Allocation. Discovered activity routine patterns were then mapped to six categorized activity routines.
Using the rule-based approach, activity routines could be discovered with an average accuracy of 76% across all patients. The rule-based approach outperformed clustering by 10% and showed less confusions for predicted activity routines.
Topic models are suitable to discover daily life activity routines in hemiparetic rehabilitation patients without trained classifiers and activity annotations. Activity routines show characteristic patterns regarding activity primitives including body and extremity postures and movement. A patient-independent rule set can be derived. Including expert knowledge supports successful activity routine discovery over completely data-driven clustering.
监测偏瘫康复患者一整天的自然行为和活动规律,可为治疗师和患者提供有价值的进展信息,并有助于优化康复过程。特别是,持续的患者监测可以补充日常生活活动规律的类型、频率和持续时间,从而补充仅针对特定任务评估的标准临床评分。机器学习方法已被应用于从传感器数据中推断活动规律。然而,监督方法需要活动注释来构建识别模型,因此需要对患者进行广泛监督。包括主题模型在内的发现方法可以提供患者的日常活动信息,并处理不同患者在活动和运动表现方面的差异。主题模型已被用于利用从监督传感器数据中识别出的活动原语来发现健康个体的特征活动规律模式。然而,主题模型在偏瘫康复患者中的适用性以及无需监督即可导出活动原语的技术仍有待探讨。
我们研究,1)基于主题模型的活动规律发现框架是否可以从可穿戴运动传感器数据中推断出康复患者的活动规律。2) 我们比较了基于规则和基于聚类的活动词汇表在基于主题模型的活动规律发现中的性能。
我们分析了一个数据集,该数据集由11名偏瘫康复患者在日间门诊康复中心进行记录,每位患者最多记录10个完整的记录日,使用连接在双腕和未受影响大腿上的可穿戴运动传感器。我们引入并比较了基于规则和基于聚类的活动词汇表,以将统计和频率加速度特征处理为活动词。使用基于潜在狄利克雷分配的主题模型,将活动词用于活动规律模式发现。然后将发现的活动规律模式映射到六种分类的活动规律中。
使用基于规则的方法,所有患者的活动规律发现平均准确率为76%。基于规则的方法比聚类方法的表现高出10%,并且在预测活动规律时混淆更少。
主题模型适用于在没有训练有素的分类器和活动注释的情况下发现偏瘫康复患者的日常生活活动规律。活动规律在包括身体和四肢姿势及运动的活动原语方面呈现出特征模式。可以导出一个独立于患者的规则集。纳入专家知识有助于在完全数据驱动的聚类之上成功发现活动规律。