Sverdlov E D
Ross Fiziol Zh Im I M Sechenova. 2014 May;100(5):505-41.
The review is devoted to the widely discussed problems of the feasibility of "systems biology" and "P4-personalized (systems) medicine" from the standpoint of complex living systems. The following conclusions are made. 1. It is impossible to reach the ultimate goals of systems biology and medicine based solely on data of genomics and other 'omics'. Systems biology may be efficient for an approximate description of certain functional modules provided that there are experimental data for the majority of the components of the system under study. 2. P4-personalized (systems) medicine based on systems biology is unrealistic fundamentally and technically, as well as from the economic point of view. 3. A possible way is to search for the targets common for all or for large groups of individuals, and the development of postgenomic generalized medicine. 4. Also realistic are some of currently developing options of personalized medicine, such as e. g. the use of patient stem cells that are returned to the patient after culturing, or of gene-modified infiltrating T-lymphocytes in so-called chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) cancer therapy. CAR therapy is a personalized treatment that uses T-lymphocytes taken from a patient and gene-modified in such a way that to recognize and kill cancer cells. 5. Despite of numerous claims, the paradigms of the postgenomic sciences were not changed. Traditional approaches of molecular biology, genetics, biochemistry, and physiology still remain in force in the postgenomic era. They are enforced due to the data obtained by 'omics'. These data may be a base for putting forward and testing hypotheses about the mechanisms of functional processes.
这篇综述从复杂生命系统的角度,探讨了广受讨论的“系统生物学”和“P4 个性化(系统)医学”的可行性问题。得出了以下结论。1. 仅基于基因组学和其他“组学”数据,无法实现系统生物学和医学的最终目标。如果对所研究系统的大多数组件有实验数据,系统生物学可能对某些功能模块进行近似描述是有效的。2. 基于系统生物学的 P4 个性化(系统)医学在根本、技术以及经济层面都是不现实的。3. 一种可能的方法是寻找所有个体或大群体共有的靶点,并发展后基因组广义医学。4. 目前一些正在发展的个性化医学选项也是现实可行的,例如使用培养后再回输给患者的患者干细胞,或在所谓的嵌合抗原受体(CAR)癌症治疗中使用基因修饰的浸润性 T 淋巴细胞。CAR 疗法是一种个性化治疗,它使用从患者身上获取的 T 淋巴细胞,并进行基因修饰,使其能够识别并杀死癌细胞。5. 尽管有诸多说法,但后基因组科学的范式并未改变。分子生物学、遗传学、生物化学和生理学的传统方法在 postgenomic 时代仍然有效。由于“组学”获得的数据,它们得到了强化。这些数据可能是提出和检验关于功能过程机制假设的基础。