Hern H Gene, Wills Charlotte P, Johnson Brian
Alameda Health System, Highland Hospital, Department of Emergency Medicine, Oakland, California.
West J Emerg Med. 2015 Jan;16(1):127-32. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2014.11.22982. Epub 2014 Dec 9.
Residency interview apparel has traditionally been the dark business suit. We changed the interview dress code from a traditionally established unwritten 'formal' attire to an explicitly described 'informal' attire. We sought to assess if the change in dress code attire changed applicants' perceptions of the residency program or decreased costs.
The authors conducted an anonymous survey of applicants applying to one emergency medicine residency program during two application cycles ending in 2012 and 2013. Applicants were asked if the change in dress code affected their perception of the program, comfort level, overall costs and how it affected their rank lists.
We sent the survey to 308 interviewed applicants over two years. Of those, 236 applicants completed the survey for a combined response rate of 76.6% (236/308). Among respondents, 85.1% (200 of 235) stated they appreciated the change; 66.7% (154 of 231) stated the change caused them to worry more about what to wear. Males were more uncomfortable than females due to the lack of uniformity on the interview day (18.5% of males [25/135] vs. 7.4% of females [7/95], collapsed results p-value 0.008). A total of 27.7% (64/231) agreed that the costs were less overall. The change caused 50 of 230 (21.7%) applicants to rank the program higher on their rank list and only one applicant to rank the program lower.
A change to a more informal dress code resulted in more comfort and fewer costs for applicants to a single residency program. The change also resulted in some applicants placing the program higher on their rank order list.
住院医师面试着装传统上一直是深色商务套装。我们将面试着装规范从传统既定的不成文“正式”着装改为明确规定的“非正式”着装。我们试图评估着装规范的改变是否会改变申请人对住院医师项目的看法或降低成本。
作者对在2012年和2013年结束的两个申请周期内申请一个急诊医学住院医师项目的申请人进行了匿名调查。询问申请人着装规范的改变是否影响了他们对该项目的看法、舒适度、总体成本以及这对他们的排名列表有何影响。
我们在两年内将调查问卷发送给了308名接受面试的申请人。其中,236名申请人完成了调查,综合回复率为76.6%(236/308)。在受访者中,85.1%(235人中的200人)表示他们赞赏这一改变;66.7%(231人中的154人)表示这一改变让他们更担心穿什么。由于面试当天着装缺乏统一性,男性比女性更不自在(男性为18.5%[25/135],女性为7.4%[7/95],汇总结果p值为0.008)。共有27.7%(64/231)的人认为总体成本更低。这一改变导致230名申请人中的50人(21.7%)在他们的排名列表中将该项目排得更高,只有一名申请人将该项目排得更低。
对于单一住院医师项目的申请人来说,改为更非正式的着装规范会让他们更舒适,成本也更低。这一改变还导致一些申请人在他们的排名顺序列表中将该项目排得更高。