Almquist Zack W, Butts Carter T
Department of Sociology, School of Statistics, and Minnesota Population Center, University of Minnesota, USA.
Departments of Sociology, Statistics, EECS, and The Institute for Mathematical Behavioral Sciences, University of California, Irvine, USA.
Geogr Anal. 2015 Jan;47(1):50-72. doi: 10.1111/gean.12045.
Social scientists characterize social life as a hierarchy of environments, from the micro level of an individual's knowledge and perceptions to the macro level of large-scale social networks. In accordance with this typology, individuals are typically thought to reside in micro- and macro-level structures, composed of multifaceted relations (e.g., acquaintanceship, friendship, and kinship). This article analyzes the effects of social structure on micro outcomes through the case of regional identification. Self identification occurs in many different domains, one of which is regional; i.e., the identification of oneself with a locationally-associated group (e.g., a "New Yorker" or "Parisian"). Here, regional self-identification is posited to result from an influence process based on the location of an individual's alters (e.g., friends, kin or coworkers), such that one tends to identify with regions in which many of his or her alters reside. The structure of this paper is laid out as follows: initially, we begin with a discussion of the relevant social science literature for both social networks and identification. This discussion is followed with one about competing mechanisms for regional identification that are motivated first from the social network literature, and second by the social psychological and cognitive literature of decision making and heuristics. Next, the paper covers the data and methods employed to test the proposed mechanisms. Finally, the paper concludes with a discussion of its findings and further implications for the larger social science literature.
社会科学家将社会生活描述为一个环境层次体系,从个人知识和认知的微观层面到大规模社会网络的宏观层面。按照这种类型学,个体通常被认为处于微观和宏观层面的结构中,这些结构由多方面的关系组成(例如相识关系、友谊关系和亲属关系)。本文通过区域认同的案例分析社会结构对微观结果的影响。自我认同发生在许多不同的领域,其中之一是区域认同;也就是说,将自己与一个与地理位置相关的群体联系起来(例如“纽约人”或“巴黎人”)。在此,区域自我认同被认为是由一个基于个体的他人(例如朋友、亲属或同事)所在位置的影响过程导致的,这样一个人往往会认同他或她的许多他人居住的地区。本文结构如下:首先,我们从讨论社会网络和认同的相关社会科学文献开始。接着讨论区域认同的竞争机制,这些机制首先源于社会网络文献,其次源于社会心理学以及决策和启发法的认知文献。接下来,本文介绍用于检验所提出机制的数据和方法。最后,本文以对研究结果的讨论以及对更广泛社会科学文献的进一步启示作为结论。