Dammann H G, Dreyer M, Gottlieb W R, Wolf N, Müller P, Simon B
Fortschr Med. 1989 May 10;107(14):321-4.
In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, comparative cross-over study, we studied the effect of four H2-receptor antagonists on intragastric 24-hour acidity, nocturnal volume and acid output. Ten healthy male volunteers were administered 300 mg or 150 mg nizatidine, 800 mg cimetidine, 300 mg ranitidine, 40 mg famotidine, or placebo on several days, in each case at 9:000 PM. Nocturnal intragastric H+ concentration (mmol/l) (11:00 PM to 7:00 AM) was significantly reduced by all H2 blockers compared with placebo. We obtained the following inhibition rates: Cimetidine 67%; ranitidine 95%; famotidine 89%; nizatidine 80% (300 mg) and 69% (150 mg). Nocturnal acid (mmol/l) and volume output (ml/h) were also significantly (compared with placebo) inhibited by all four H2-receptor antagonists. Inhibition of nocturnal acid secretion was almost identical on nizatidine 300 mg nocte, ranitidine 300 mg nocte, famotidine 40 mg nocte, and cimetidine 800 mg nocte. Nizatidine 300 mg nocte and 150 mg nocte exclusively reduced acid secretion at night, without an aftereffect into the following day (8:00 AM to 6:00 PM). These results suggest that the clinical efficacy of these H2-receptor antagonists is identical with respect to healing peptic ulcer disease and providing freedom from pain. It is generally accepted today that gastric acid inhibitors used in the treatment of peptic ulcer disease should interfere with daytime gastric acid secretion as little as possible, particularly since the acid protects the stomach from bacteria ingested with the food during the day.
在一项随机、双盲、安慰剂对照的比较性交叉研究中,我们研究了四种H2受体拮抗剂对胃内24小时酸度、夜间胃液量和胃酸分泌量的影响。10名健康男性志愿者在几天内于每晚9点分别服用300毫克或150毫克尼扎替丁、800毫克西咪替丁、300毫克雷尼替丁、40毫克法莫替丁或安慰剂。与安慰剂相比,所有H2受体阻滞剂均显著降低了夜间胃内H+浓度(毫摩尔/升)(晚上11点至上午7点)。我们得到了以下抑制率:西咪替丁67%;雷尼替丁95%;法莫替丁89%;尼扎替丁300毫克为80%,150毫克为69%。所有四种H2受体拮抗剂也显著抑制了夜间胃酸(毫摩尔/升)和胃液分泌量(毫升/小时)(与安慰剂相比)。300毫克尼扎替丁每晚一次、300毫克雷尼替丁每晚一次、40毫克法莫替丁每晚一次和800毫克西咪替丁每晚一次对夜间胃酸分泌的抑制作用几乎相同。300毫克尼扎替丁每晚一次和150毫克尼扎替丁每晚一次仅在夜间降低胃酸分泌,对次日(上午8点至下午6点)无后续影响。这些结果表明,这些H2受体拮抗剂在治疗消化性溃疡疾病和缓解疼痛方面的临床疗效相同。如今人们普遍认为,用于治疗消化性溃疡疾病的胃酸抑制剂应尽可能少地干扰白天的胃酸分泌,特别是因为胃酸在白天可保护胃免受随食物摄入的细菌侵害。