New School for Social Research, New York, New York.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2013 Sep;1299:11-24. doi: 10.1111/nyas.12275.
Conflicts over sacred values may be particularly difficult to resolve. Because sacred values are nonfungible with material values, standard attempts to negotiate, such as offering material incentives to compromise, often backfire, increasing moral outrage and support for violent action. We present studies with Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza demonstrating three other ways sacred values may make conflict more intractable, focusing on what we call devoted actors, people who regard issues central to the Israel-Palestine conflict as sacred values. We show that devoted actors (1) were less amenable to social influence, (2) perceived conflict-related events in the past as well as expected events in the future to be temporally closer, and (3) were blind to individual opportunities to escape the conflict. These results suggest that sacred values may affect decision making in a number of ways, which, when combined, contribute to common defense and continuation of conflict.
对于神圣价值的冲突可能尤其难以解决。因为神圣价值与物质价值不可互换,所以标准的谈判尝试,如提供物质激励来妥协,往往会适得其反,增加道德愤慨和对暴力行动的支持。我们提出了在西岸和加沙地带的巴勒斯坦人进行的研究,展示了神圣价值可能使冲突更加棘手的另外三种方式,重点关注我们称之为虔诚行为者的人,这些人将与以色列-巴勒斯坦冲突有关的核心问题视为神圣价值。我们表明,虔诚的行为者(1)更不易受社会影响,(2)过去对冲突相关事件以及未来的预期事件的感知时间更接近,(3)对逃避冲突的个人机会视而不见。这些结果表明,神圣价值可能以多种方式影响决策,这些方式结合在一起,导致共同防御和冲突的持续。