Bamoulid Jamal, Staeck Oliver, Halleck Fabian, Khadzhynov Dmytri, Brakemeier Susanne, Dürr Michael, Budde Klemens
Department of Nephrology, Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Transpl Int. 2015 Aug;28(8):891-900. doi: 10.1111/tri.12553. Epub 2015 Mar 18.
New immunosuppressants and the better use of immunosuppressant combination therapy have led to significant improvements in renal allograft outcomes over the last decades. Yet, despite dramatic reduction in rejection rates and improvement in 1-year graft survival, long-term graft attrition rates remained rather constant. Current immunosuppressant combinations are frequently leading to overimmunosuppression and are increasing cardiovascular risk. Importantly, calcineurin inhibitors are nephrotoxic, contribute to cardiovascular risk and chronic allograft dysfunction. Furthermore, immunosuppressant-associated toxicities aggravate immune-mediated nephron injury and side effects lead to nonadherence, an identified important reason for late acute and chronic antibody-mediated rejections. The frequent development of a chronic humoral response indicates rather insufficient immunosuppression of current combinations than simple under-immunosuppression. While there is no evidence that increasing immunosuppressive doses will improve outcomes or reduce de novo HLA-antibody formation, there is clear evidence that adequate minimization strategies will reduce side effect burden. Because of low rejection risk, but frequent side effects, drug minimization is particularly relevant for the many maintenance patients. In summary, new therapeutic strategies need to be developed from adequately powered clinical trials for reduction of the many side effects of immunosuppressants. Such evidence-based and time-dependent immunosuppressive minimization strategies are needed to achieve better long-term outcomes in the future.
在过去几十年中,新型免疫抑制剂以及免疫抑制剂联合疗法的优化使用使肾移植受者的预后得到显著改善。然而,尽管排斥反应率大幅降低,1年移植肾存活率有所提高,但长期移植肾失功率仍相当稳定。目前的免疫抑制剂联合疗法常常导致免疫抑制过度,并增加心血管疾病风险。重要的是,钙调神经磷酸酶抑制剂具有肾毒性,会增加心血管疾病风险并导致慢性移植肾失功。此外,免疫抑制剂相关毒性会加重免疫介导的肾单位损伤,其副作用会导致患者依从性差,这是晚期急性和慢性抗体介导排斥反应的一个重要原因。慢性体液反应的频繁发生表明,目前联合疗法的免疫抑制作用并非简单的不足,而是不够充分。虽然没有证据表明增加免疫抑制剂量会改善预后或减少新生HLA抗体的形成,但有明确证据表明适当的最小化策略将减轻副作用负担。由于排斥风险低但副作用频繁,药物最小化对许多维持治疗的患者尤为重要。总之,需要通过充分有力的临床试验来制定新的治疗策略,以减少免疫抑制剂的诸多副作用。未来需要这种基于证据且随时间变化的免疫抑制最小化策略,以实现更好的长期预后。