Lazzaroni M, Bianchi Porro G
Gastrointestinal Unit, L. Sacco Hospital, Milano, Italy.
Hepatogastroenterology. 1989 Dec;36(6):490-3.
The aim of this study was to compare the inhibitory effect and duration of action of a new H2-antagonist, nizatidine (150 mg per os), with ranitidine (150 mg per os) in a group of 10 patients with healed duodenal ulcer. The total inhibitory effect on acid output observed under basal conditions (30 min), during pentagastrin stimulation (120 min) and after stimulation (60 min), is overlapping. However, nizatidine showed a more rapid inhibitory activity -80%, and 31% higher than ranitidine with regard to basal acid output and maximum acid output, during the first hour of stimulation. On the other hand, ranitidine has a more prolonged antisecretory action--more than 27% and 54%, respectively, with regard to maximum acid output during the second hour and the period after hormonal stimulation. Also, variations in pepsin and acid output resulted in overlapping. In conclusion, these results, explainable by the pharmacodynamic property of the two drugs, confirmed the excellent inhibitory capacity of nizatidine, and furnish another reason for its use in clinical practice.
本研究旨在比较新型H2拮抗剂尼扎替丁(口服150毫克)与雷尼替丁(口服150毫克)对一组10例十二指肠溃疡已愈合患者的抑制作用及作用持续时间。在基础条件下(30分钟)、五肽胃泌素刺激期间(120分钟)和刺激后(60分钟)观察到的对胃酸分泌的总体抑制作用是重叠的。然而,尼扎替丁显示出更快的抑制活性——在刺激的第一个小时,就基础胃酸分泌量和最大胃酸分泌量而言,比雷尼替丁分别高80%和31%。另一方面,雷尼替丁具有更持久的抗分泌作用——在第二个小时以及激素刺激后的时间段内,就最大胃酸分泌量而言,分别比尼扎替丁多27%和54%。此外,胃蛋白酶和胃酸分泌量的变化也相互重叠。总之,这些结果可通过两种药物的药效学特性来解释,证实了尼扎替丁具有出色的抑制能力,并为其在临床实践中的应用提供了另一个依据。