Tanabe T, Yoshikawa H, Tagawa R, Furuya H, Ide M, Goto Y
Jpn Circ J. 1985 Mar;49(3):337-44. doi: 10.1253/jcj.49.337.
This study was performed to investigate spontaneous variability in VPC frequency, to determine standards for distinguishing antiarrhythmic efficacy from the spontaneous variability, and to compare the effectiveness of disopyramide, mexiletine, aprindine, propranolol, and diltiazem. Holter ECG techniques were used for this study and the population studied consisted of 182 patients having more than 1000 VPCs/day. Forty patients had ischemic heart disease, 52 had miscellaneous heart disease and 90 were free of heart disease (idiopathic VPCs). Circadian variability of VPCs can be divided into 4 types; Type D (VPCs increasing during waking hours), Type DN (small VPC changes between waking and sleeping hours), Type N (VPCs increasing during sleeping hours) and Type Ir (irregularly occurring VPCs). The incidence of Type D, DN, N and Ir was 45%, 29%, 12% and 14%, respectively. VPC frequency in the first and second recordings at a 7 up to 21 day interval was highly reproducible (r = 0.951). The percent reduction in VPC frequency necessary to distinguish true drug response from spontaneous VPC variability, corresponded to 57% with 95% confidence level, and 67% with 99% confidence level. VPCs were reduced by at least 57% in 19 out of 33 patients (58%) with disopyramide, 9 of 15 (60%) with mexiletine, 11 of 18 (61%) with aprindine, 9 of 24 (38%) with propranolol and 8 of 22 (36%) with diltiazem. Concerning Prop., it is exclusively effective to the Type D VPCs (70%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
本研究旨在调查室性早搏(VPC)频率的自发变异性,确定区分抗心律失常疗效与自发变异性的标准,并比较丙吡胺、美西律、阿普林定、普萘洛尔和地尔硫䓬的有效性。本研究采用动态心电图技术,研究人群包括182例每日VPC超过1000次的患者。40例患有缺血性心脏病,52例患有其他心脏病,90例无心脏病(特发性VPC)。VPC的昼夜变异性可分为4种类型:D型(清醒时VPC增加)、DN型(清醒和睡眠时VPC变化小)、N型(睡眠时VPC增加)和Ir型(VPC不规则出现)。D型、DN型、N型和Ir型的发生率分别为45%、29%、12%和14%。在7至21天间隔的第一次和第二次记录中,VPC频率具有高度可重复性(r = 0.951)。将真正的药物反应与自发的VPC变异性区分开来所需的VPC频率降低百分比,在95%置信水平下为57%,在99%置信水平下为67%。33例使用丙吡胺的患者中有19例(58%)、15例使用美西律的患者中有9例(60%)、18例使用阿普林定的患者中有11例(61%)、24例使用普萘洛尔的患者中有9例(38%)、22例使用地尔硫䓬的患者中有8例(36%)的VPC至少降低了57%。关于普萘洛尔,它仅对D型VPC有效(70%)。(摘要截断于250字)