Chatterjee Sandip, Das Amitabha
Park Clinic, 4 Gorky Terrace, Kolkata, 700017, India,
Childs Nerv Syst. 2015 Aug;31(8):1341-5. doi: 10.1007/s00381-015-2695-5. Epub 2015 Apr 15.
The aim of this study was to review cases of paediatric patients with craniovertebral junction (CVJ) tuberculosis with a view to try and stratify the cases into different groups which would help plan treatment and hence develop a protocol for treatment of a fairly uncommon condition still widely seen in the developing world.
Twenty-three cases of paediatric craniovertebral tuberculosis had their clinical features and radiology reviewed. The treatment plan in each case was analyzed according to their presentation. The results of treatment after 1 year were assessed in each case.
The clinical presentations varied from neck pain with hypoglossal nerve palsy to frank spastic quadriparesis, and frank instability at the atlanto-axial junction was seen in five out of 23 patients. Cold abscesses were seen in 18/23 cases, and severe torticollis was the presentation in 6/23. We graded the children with this condition into three groups: 1) those with instability and gross neurodeficit who required early operative intervention (1 needed trans-oral decompression with posterior fixation and 4 required posterior fixation) 2) those who had severe torticollis and large cold abscesses who were treated with trans-oral aspiration of cold abscess followed by neck immobilization (6/23) and 3) those who did not have significant neck muscle spasm or torticollis and who were treated with immobilization alone (12/23). Only one child in group 3 required delayed intervention for instability which developed after completion of the course of anti-tubercular medication.
We concluded that children with craniovertebral tuberculosis should be treated according to their clinical presentation coupled with evidence of radiological instability. Those with gross deficit and instability need early stabilization, those with minimal deficit and no instability but severe pain or torticollis need aspiration of the cold abscess with external immobilization, whereas those without deficit, instability or severe pain may be managed by external orthoses alone. Of course, medical treatment for tuberculosis is necessary in each case.
本研究旨在回顾小儿颅颈交界区(CVJ)结核病例,试图将病例分为不同组,这将有助于制定治疗计划,从而为这种在发展中国家仍广泛存在的相当罕见的疾病制定治疗方案。
对23例小儿颅颈结核病例的临床特征和影像学进行回顾。根据每个病例的表现分析其治疗方案。评估每个病例1年后的治疗结果。
临床表现从伴有舌下神经麻痹的颈部疼痛到明显的痉挛性四肢瘫,23例患者中有5例出现寰枢关节明显不稳定。23例中有18例出现寒性脓肿,23例中有6例以严重斜颈为表现。我们将患有这种疾病的儿童分为三组:1)有不稳定和严重神经功能缺损需要早期手术干预的患者(1例需要经口减压并后路固定,4例需要后路固定);2)有严重斜颈和大寒性脓肿的患者,先经口抽吸寒性脓肿,然后颈部固定(23例中的6例);3)没有明显颈部肌肉痉挛或斜颈,仅接受固定治疗的患者(23例中的12例)。第3组中只有1名儿童在抗结核药物疗程结束后因出现不稳定而需要延迟干预。
我们得出结论,颅颈结核患儿应根据其临床表现及影像学不稳定证据进行治疗。有严重功能缺损和不稳定的患儿需要早期稳定,功能缺损最小且无不稳定但有严重疼痛或斜颈的患儿需要抽吸寒性脓肿并外部固定,而无功能缺损、不稳定或严重疼痛的患儿可仅用外部支具治疗。当然每个病例都需要进行抗结核药物治疗。